Stone P H, Krantz D S, McMahon R P, Goldberg A D, Becker L C, Chaitman B R, Taylor H A, Cohen J D, Freedland K E, Bertolet B D, Coughlan C, Pepine C J, Kaufmann P G, Sheps D S
Harvard Medical School and Brigham and Women's Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts, USA.
J Am Coll Cardiol. 1999 May;33(6):1476-84. doi: 10.1016/s0735-1097(99)00075-3.
The purposes of this database study were to determine: 1) the relationship between mental stress-induced ischemia and ischemia during daily life and during exercise; 2) whether patients who exhibited daily life ischemia experienced greater hemodynamic and catecholamine responses to mental or physical stress than patients who did not exhibit daily life ischemia, and 3) whether patients who experienced daily life ischemia could be identified on the basis of laboratory-induced ischemia using mental or exercise stress testing.
The relationships between mental stress-induced ischemia in the laboratory and ischemia during daily life and during exercise are unclear.
One hundred ninety-six stable patients with documented coronary disease and a positive exercise test underwent mental stress testing and bicycle exercise testing. Radionuclide ventriculography and electrocardiographic (ECG) monitoring were performed during the mental stress and bicycle tests. Patients underwent 48 h of ambulatory ECG monitoring. Hemodynamic and catecholamine responses were obtained during mental stress and bicycle tests.
Ischemia (reversible left ventricular dysfunction or ST segment depression > or = 1 mm) developed in 106 of 183 patients (58%) during the mental stress test. There were no significant differences in clinical characteristics of patients with, compared with those without, mental stress-induced ischemia. Patients with mental stress ischemia more often had daily life ischemia than patients without mental stress ischemia, but their exercise tests were similar. Patients with daily life ischemia had higher ejection fraction and cardiac output, and lower systemic vascular resistance during mental stress than patients without daily life ischemia. Blood pressure and catecholamine levels at rest and during the mental stress tests were not different in patients with, compared with those without, daily life ischemia. Patients with daily life ischemia had a higher ejection fraction at rest and at peak bicycle exercise compared with patients without daily life ischemia, but there were no other differences in peak hemodynamic or catecholamine responses to exercise. The presence of ST segment depression during routine daily activities was best predicted by ST segment depression during mental or bicycle exercise stress, although ST segment depression was rare during mental stress.
Patients with daily life ischemia exhibit a heightened generalized response to mental stress. ST segment depression in response to mental or exercise stress is more predictive of ST segment depression during routine daily activities than other laboratory-based ischemic markers. Therapeutic management strategies might therefore focus on patients with these physiologic responses to stress and on whether lessening such responses reduces ischemia.
本数据库研究的目的是确定:1)精神应激诱导的缺血与日常生活及运动期间缺血之间的关系;2)出现日常生活缺血的患者相比于未出现日常生活缺血的患者,对精神或身体应激是否表现出更大的血流动力学和儿茶酚胺反应;3)能否通过精神或运动应激试验,根据实验室诱导的缺血来识别经历日常生活缺血的患者。
实验室中精神应激诱导的缺血与日常生活及运动期间缺血之间的关系尚不清楚。
196例有冠心病记录且运动试验阳性的稳定患者接受了精神应激试验和自行车运动试验。在精神应激和自行车试验期间进行放射性核素心室造影和心电图(ECG)监测。患者接受了48小时的动态心电图监测。在精神应激和自行车试验期间获取血流动力学和儿茶酚胺反应。
在精神应激试验期间,183例患者中有106例(58%)出现缺血(可逆性左心室功能障碍或ST段压低≥1mm)。有精神应激诱导缺血的患者与无精神应激诱导缺血的患者在临床特征上无显著差异。有精神应激缺血的患者比无精神应激缺血的患者更常出现日常生活缺血,但他们的运动试验结果相似。与无日常生活缺血的患者相比,有日常生活缺血的患者在精神应激期间射血分数更高、心输出量更高,而全身血管阻力更低。有日常生活缺血的患者与无日常生活缺血的患者在静息时以及精神应激试验期间的血压和儿茶酚胺水平无差异。与无日常生活缺血的患者相比,有日常生活缺血的患者在静息时和自行车运动峰值时射血分数更高,但在运动峰值时的血流动力学或儿茶酚胺反应无其他差异。尽管精神应激期间ST段压低很少见,但日常活动期间ST段压低的出现最好通过精神或自行车运动应激期间的ST段压低来预测。
有日常生活缺血的患者对精神应激表现出增强的全身性反应。相比于其他基于实验室的缺血标志物,精神或运动应激时的ST段压低对日常活动期间的ST段压低更具预测性。因此,治疗管理策略可能应关注对这些应激有生理反应的患者,以及减轻这种反应是否能减少缺血。