Ortín Castaño A, López Alburquerque T, Adeva Bartolomé M T, González Buitrago J M
Servicio de Neurología, Hospital Clínico Universitario, Salamanca.
An Med Interna. 1999 Apr;16(4):167-70.
There is some controversy in the medical literature concerning the need to perform neuroimaging studies in neurologically normal patients complaining of headaches. The objective of the study is to determine the detection rate of intracranial abnormalities by computed tomography in patients with different headache durations.
Consecutive patients with the chief complaint of headache referred for neurological evaluation from January 1996 to April 1997 were studied both clinically and by computed tomography scanning. Brain magnetic resonance imaging was performed in 15 patients. Cerebrospinal fluid and/or blood analyses were performed when clinically indicated to rule out subarachnoid hemorrhage, meningitis or temporal arteritis.
15 (5%) out of the 299 patients available for study had significant intracranial lesion. 3 (1%) out of the 266 patients with headaches lasting for more than 1 month had computed tomography findings considered clinically significant and neurological examination was normal in 2 (0.7%) patients with abnormal scans. Patients with a headache duration of 1 month or less had the following case-finding rate: an overall significant intracranial abnormality of 36% (12/33) and significant intracranial abnormality in neurologically normal patients of 15% (5/33).
Patients with headache of recent onset (duration of 1 month or less), even with normal neurological examination, are at greater risk of significant intracranial abnormality than patients with long-lasting headaches. These patients at risk should be studied by cranial computed tomography and lumbar puncture if the computed tomography scan is normal and the cause of the headaches cannot be clinically determined.
医学文献中对于无神经系统症状但主诉头痛的患者是否需要进行神经影像学检查存在一些争议。本研究的目的是确定不同头痛持续时间的患者通过计算机断层扫描检测颅内异常的比率。
对1996年1月至1997年4月因头痛为主诉前来接受神经科评估的连续患者进行临床和计算机断层扫描研究。对15名患者进行了脑磁共振成像检查。根据临床指征进行脑脊液和/或血液分析,以排除蛛网膜下腔出血、脑膜炎或颞动脉炎。
在可供研究的299名患者中,15名(5%)有明显的颅内病变。在266名头痛持续超过1个月的患者中,3名(1%)的计算机断层扫描结果被认为具有临床意义,在扫描异常的2名(0.7%)患者中,神经系统检查正常。头痛持续时间为1个月或更短的患者的病例发现率如下:总体明显颅内异常为36%(12/33),神经系统正常患者的明显颅内异常为15%(5/33)。
近期发作(持续时间为1个月或更短)的头痛患者,即使神经系统检查正常,相比于长期头痛患者,发生明显颅内异常的风险更高。对于这些有风险的患者,如果计算机断层扫描正常且头痛原因无法通过临床确定,应进行头颅计算机断层扫描和腰椎穿刺检查。