Forst J, Forst R
Orthopaedic Department, University Hospital RWTH Aachen, Germany.
Neuromuscul Disord. 1999 May;9(3):176-81. doi: 10.1016/s0960-8966(98)00113-8.
Two hundred and thirteen of 428 patients with Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) of a prospective and open study were operated on bilaterally with hip and knee release, aponeurectomy of the iliotibial band and Achilles tendon lengthening. In 87 patients the operation was carried out during early restrictions of the lower limb joint mobility at an average age of 6.56 years (4.02-8.26, SD 1.42). The follow-up was on average 5.4 years (0.25-9.01, SD 2.7). This group was compared to a control group (natural history) consisting of 100 non-operated DMD patients. A significant (P < 0.001) release of the contractures could be obtained. Loss of walking ability occurred in the control group at an average of 9.29 years (5.85-13.63, SD 1.98) and in the operated group at an average of 10.55 years (8.17-14.39, SD 1.76). This shows that early lower limb surgery leads to a prolongation of independent ambulation of 1.25 years on average. In contrast to the patients of the control group all treated patients between ages 6 and 8 years could walk independently. The positive influence of early lower limb surgery could also be shown by the development of Hammersmith motor ability score, CIDD (Council of Investigation of Duchenne Dystrophy) grading and Vignos scale. Nevertheless, in consideration of the well-known course of DMD not only the prolongation of ambulation but also the achieved prolongation of assisted standing ability with no or mild contractures are aims of lower limb surgery. Since no improvement of muscle strength could be observed after lower limb surgery, further studies have to investigate if additionally administered steroids can prolong ambulation after early lower limb surgery.
在一项前瞻性开放研究中,428例杜氏肌营养不良症(DMD)患者中有213例接受了双侧髋关节和膝关节松解、髂胫束腱膜切除术以及跟腱延长术。87例患者在下肢关节活动度早期受限期间接受了手术,平均年龄为6.56岁(4.02 - 8.26岁,标准差1.42)。随访平均时间为5.4年(0.25 - 9.01年,标准差2.7)。该组与由100例未接受手术的DMD患者组成的对照组(自然病程组)进行了比较。挛缩得到了显著缓解(P < 0.001)。对照组平均在9.29岁(5.85 - 13.63岁,标准差1.98)时丧失行走能力,手术组平均在10.55岁(8.17 - 14.39岁,标准差1.76)时丧失行走能力。这表明早期下肢手术平均可使独立行走时间延长1.25年。与对照组患者不同,所有6至8岁接受治疗的患者都能独立行走。早期下肢手术的积极影响还体现在哈默史密斯运动能力评分、杜氏肌营养不良症研究委员会(CIDD)分级和维格诺斯量表的变化上。然而,考虑到DMD的已知病程,下肢手术的目标不仅是延长行走时间,还包括在无挛缩或轻度挛缩的情况下延长辅助站立能力。由于下肢手术后未观察到肌肉力量改善,进一步的研究必须探讨额外使用类固醇是否能在早期下肢手术后延长行走时间。