Losken H W, Mooney M P, Zoldos J, Tschakaloff A, Burrows A M, Smith T D, Cano G, Arnott R, Sherwood C, Dechant J, Cooper G M, Kapucu M R, Siegel M I
Department of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, University of Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, PA 15261, USA.
J Craniofac Surg. 1999 Jan;10(1):27-37. doi: 10.1097/00001665-199901000-00007.
Recent studies have identified a subpopulation of persons with craniosynostosis who exhibit progressive or delayed-onset synostosis and mild cranial vault deformities. These persons may be good candidates for nonextirpation distraction osteogenesis. The present studies were designed to determine force-displacement parameters and assess the effects of distraction osteogenesis on coronal suture growth and morphologic characteristics in a rabbit model with congenital, delayed-onset craniosynostosis. Data were collected from a total of 178 rabbits: 71 normal controls; 16 normal controls with distraction; 72 with delayed-onset coronal suture synostosis; and 19 with delayed-onset coronal suture synostosis and distraction. At 10 days of age, all rabbits had amalgam markers placed on both sides of the coronal suture. In the force-displacement study, force-displacement distractors were placed across the coronal suture and distracted acutely for 1.0 mm at 42 days of age. Force-displacement curves for the coronal suture were best described by a third-order polynomial regression equation for both normal and synostosed groups. Significant differences (P < 0.05) were found in the mean force necessary to distract a normal suture 1 mm in distance (13.72 kg) compared with a suture with delayed-onset synostosis (48.39 kg). A significant (P < 0.05) relationship was also found between the extent of synostosis and the distractive force in rabbits with delayed-onset synostosis. In the distraction study, internal distractors were fixed across the coronal suture at 25 days of age and percutaneously and intermittently activated at an average of 0.11 mm/day for 42 days (4.54 mm total). Serial radiographs were taken at 10, 25, 42, and 84 days of age. Results revealed that rabbits with delayed-onset synostosis and distraction had significantly (P < 0.01) more coronal suture growth rates compared with rabbits with delayed-onset synostosis and no distraction. Coronal sutures were harvested at 84 days of age for qualitative histologic examination. Normal, distracted coronal sutures showed widened sutural ligaments and thin, active osteogenic fronts. In contrast, distracted coronal sutures from rabbits with delayed-onset synostosis showed narrowed sutural ligaments, thickened and blunt osteogenic fronts, and increased collagen and bony matrix deposition compared with controls. Results suggest that distraction osteogenesis without corticotomy may be a treatment alternative in persons with progressive, delayed-onset synostosis. However, these preliminary data also suggest that distractive forces may accelerate or stimulate osteogenesis differentially in persons with craniosynostosis, possibly through an underlying genetic disorder of bone and cytokine regulation. These differential osteogenic responses to distraction, if validated clinically, will need to be taken into account when planning distraction rate and rhythm protocols for patients with craniosynostosis.
最近的研究已经确定了颅缝早闭患者的一个亚群,这些患者表现出进行性或迟发性缝闭以及轻度的颅穹窿畸形。这些人可能是非切除性牵张成骨的理想候选者。目前的研究旨在确定力-位移参数,并评估牵张成骨对先天性迟发性颅缝早闭兔模型中冠状缝生长和形态特征的影响。总共从178只兔子收集了数据:71只正常对照;16只进行牵张的正常对照;72只患有迟发性冠状缝早闭;19只患有迟发性冠状缝早闭并进行牵张。在10日龄时,所有兔子在冠状缝两侧放置汞合金标记物。在力-位移研究中,在42日龄时将力-位移牵张器放置在冠状缝上并急性牵张1.0毫米。正常组和缝闭组的冠状缝力-位移曲线最好用三阶多项式回归方程来描述。在将正常缝牵张1毫米所需的平均力(13.72千克)与迟发性缝闭的缝(48.39千克)之间发现了显著差异(P < 0.05)。在迟发性缝闭的兔子中,缝闭程度与牵张力之间也发现了显著(P < 0.05)关系。在牵张研究中,在25日龄时将内部牵张器固定在冠状缝上,并经皮间歇性激活,平均每天0.11毫米,持续42天(总共4.54毫米)。在10、25、42和84日龄时拍摄系列X线片。结果显示,与未进行牵张的迟发性缝闭兔子相比,进行牵张的迟发性缝闭兔子的冠状缝生长速率显著更高(P < 0.01)。在84日龄时采集冠状缝进行定性组织学检查。正常的、进行牵张的冠状缝显示缝合韧带增宽以及薄的、活跃的成骨前沿。相比之下,与对照组相比,迟发性缝闭兔子的牵张冠状缝显示缝合韧带变窄、成骨前沿增厚且钝圆,以及胶原和骨基质沉积增加。结果表明,不进行皮质切开术的牵张成骨可能是进行性、迟发性缝闭患者的一种治疗选择。然而,这些初步数据也表明,牵张力可能在颅缝早闭患者中以不同方式加速或刺激成骨,可能是通过潜在的骨和细胞因子调节的遗传疾病。如果这些对牵张的不同成骨反应在临床上得到验证,那么在为颅缝早闭患者制定牵张速率和节奏方案时将需要考虑到这一点。