Ghauri R R, Gunter A A, Weber R A
Scott & White Clinic and Memorial Hospital, Texas A&M University Health Science Center, College of Medicine, Temple 76508, USA.
Ann Plast Surg. 1999 Aug;43(2):156-60.
Frozen section analysis is used routinely to ensure complete removal of basal cell and squamous cell carcinomas of the skin, but the current emphasis on controlling costs raises the question as to which lesions should be evaluated with frozen section histology. A retrospective study of the clinical records and pathological reports of 51 patients selected randomly from a total of 225 patients was undertaken to determine the overall impact of frozen section analysis on the surgical management of skin cancers at this institution. The results indicate that frozen section analysis was performed on 76% of the 277 lesions evaluated, and that the results of frozen section examination were 91.1% accurate in detecting the presence or absence of tumor involvement at the surgical margins. The data also showed that the surgeons were able to estimate the margin of the skin tumor clinically and remove it entirely during the first excision 91.1% of the time. The lesions that had not been removed completely with the initial excision were those located on the periorbital region, forehead, and cheeks; were recurrent lesions; or were lesions that required more involved reconstruction than primary closure. This study shows that frozen section analysis is a valuable tool in selected situations, but routine use is not indicated for the majority of basal and squamous cell carcinomas of the skin.
冰冻切片分析常用于确保皮肤基底细胞癌和鳞状细胞癌被完全切除,但当前对控制成本的强调引发了一个问题,即哪些病变应通过冰冻切片组织学进行评估。我们对从225例患者中随机选取的51例患者的临床记录和病理报告进行了回顾性研究,以确定冰冻切片分析对本机构皮肤癌手术治疗的总体影响。结果表明,在评估的277个病变中,76%进行了冰冻切片分析,冰冻切片检查在检测手术切缘有无肿瘤累及方面的准确率为91.1%。数据还显示,外科医生能够在临床上估计皮肤肿瘤的切缘,并在首次切除时91.1%的情况下将其完全切除。初次切除未完全切除的病变位于眶周区域、前额和脸颊;为复发性病变;或为需要比一期缝合更复杂重建的病变。这项研究表明,冰冻切片分析在特定情况下是一种有价值的工具,但对于大多数皮肤基底细胞癌和鳞状细胞癌,不建议常规使用。