Court C, Gauliard C, Nordin J Y
Service d'orthopédie et de traumatologie, Hôpital Bicêtre, Le Kremlin-Bicêtre, France.
Rev Chir Orthop Reparatrice Appar Mot. 1999 Jul;85(4):404-10.
Arthroscopic arthrolysis is a reliable technique for the treatment of knee stiffness due to arthrofibrosis following ligament replacement or following the treatment of knee fracture. However, its use is uncommon for this indication in total knee arthroplasty (TKA). In this study, we questioned whether or not arthroscopy is a reliable technique for treatment of knee stiffness following TKA, due to arthrofibrosis.
Four men mean aged 54 (38-70) underwent knee arthroscopy for a history of arthrofibrosis following TKA. In two cases the arthrofibrosis had appeared after a primary TKA done for limited range of motion and in two other cases had followed a revision arthroplasty. The mean knee flexion before the TKA was 80 degrees (40-110) and it was 105 degrees (100-120) after performing the TKA. The knees were not mobilized under anesthesia though the mean flexion was 75 degrees (60-80) 15 days after the TKA. The indication for arthroscopy was a painless limited range of motion of the knee. The arthroscopy was performed 6 months (2.5-12) after the TKA and at this time the flexion was limited to 65 degrees (60-80). The extension was limited in 2 cases to 10 degrees and 30 degrees. Patients were evaluated an average of 20 months (8-36) after the arthroscopy. With 2 peripatellar portals we sectioned the adhesions in the suprapatellar pouch, the 2 retinaculars and the adhesive bands in the 2 gutters. Two anterior additional portals were used in case of extension lag. A suction drain was placed and the portals were sutured. A continuous passive motion machine was started in the recovery room.
The mean operating time for arthroscopic arthrolysis was 38 minutes (30-60). The mean knee flexion was 116 degrees (100-130) at the end of arthroscopy and was 93 degrees (75-110) at the last review. The mean flexion improved by 31 degrees (15-50). The mean flexion improved by 45% (25-83). The 2 extension lags decreased respectively from 30 degrees to 10 degrees and from 10 degrees to 0 degree. For these 2 patients the increase in range of motion was 70 degrees and 40 degrees respectively. The average amount of bleeding was 200 ml (86-520). There were no complications.
Few surgeons are experienced in arthroscopy for knee stiffness after TKA. Our results are similar to those reported by most authors. Regarding the technique, the section of the two retinaculars is necessary for the mobility of the patellar and most of the mobility is gained after the release of the gutters. The use of only two portals avoids damaging the TKA component and decreases the theoretical risk of infection. The major loss of motion after arthrolysis occurred during the first days following the arthroscopy. This is why we recommend using a regional anesthesia for the arthroscopy and during the following days to allow intensive mobilization of the knee. The arthrolysis should be done from 3 to 6 months after the TKA for better results.
Arthroscopy for the treatment of knee stiffness, due to arthrofibrosis, following TKA is a useful, reliable and safe technique.
关节镜下关节松解术是治疗韧带置换术后或膝关节骨折治疗后因关节纤维化导致膝关节僵硬的可靠技术。然而,在全膝关节置换术(TKA)中,这种适应症的应用并不常见。在本研究中,我们质疑关节镜检查对于治疗TKA后因关节纤维化导致的膝关节僵硬是否是一种可靠的技术。
4名平均年龄54岁(38 - 70岁)的男性因TKA后关节纤维化病史接受了膝关节镜检查。其中2例关节纤维化出现在初次TKA后,原因是活动范围受限,另外2例出现在翻修关节置换术后。TKA前膝关节平均屈曲度为80度(40 - 110度),TKA后为105度(100 - 120度)。尽管TKA后15天平均屈曲度为75度(60 - 80度),但未在麻醉下进行膝关节活动。关节镜检查的适应症是膝关节无痛性活动范围受限。关节镜检查在TKA后6个月(2.5 - 12个月)进行,此时屈曲度限制在65度(60 - 80度)。2例患者伸直受限分别为10度和30度。患者在关节镜检查后平均20个月(8 - 36个月)接受评估。通过两个髌旁切口,我们切开了髌上囊、两条支持带和两个髁间沟的粘连带。如有伸直延迟,则使用另外两个前侧切口。放置了吸引引流管并缝合了切口。在恢复室启动了持续被动运动机器。
关节镜下关节松解术的平均手术时间为38分钟(30 - 60分钟)。关节镜检查结束时膝关节平均屈曲度为116度(100 - 130度),最后一次复查时为93度(75 - 110度)。平均屈曲度改善了31度(15 - 50度)。平均屈曲度改善了45%(25 - 83%)。2例伸直延迟分别从30度降至10度和从10度降至0度。这2例患者的活动范围增加分别为70度和40度。平均出血量为200毫升(86 - 520毫升)。无并发症发生。
很少有外科医生在TKA后膝关节僵硬的关节镜检查方面有经验。我们的结果与大多数作者报道的结果相似。关于技术,切开两条支持带对于髌骨的活动是必要的,并且大部分活动度在切开髁间沟后获得。仅使用两个切口可避免损坏TKA部件并降低理论上的感染风险。关节松解术后活动度的主要损失发生在关节镜检查后的头几天。这就是为什么我们建议在关节镜检查时以及随后几天使用区域麻醉,以便对膝关节进行强化活动。关节松解术应在TKA后3至个月进行,以获得更好的效果。
关节镜检查用于治疗TKA后因关节纤维化导致的膝关节僵硬是一种有用、可靠且安全的技术。