Coyte P C, Young W
Department of Health Administration, Toronto, Ont.
CMAJ. 1999 Aug 24;161(4):376-80.
Although regional variations in the use of many health care services have been reported, little attention has been devoted to home care practices. Given the dramatic shift in care settings from hospitals to private homes, it is important to determine the extent to which home care practices vary by geographic region.
Data from the Canadian Institute for Health Information and the Ontario Home Care Administration System database were used to assess regional variations in rates of home care use following inpatient care and same-day surgery for the fiscal years 1993, 1994 and 1995. Various measures of regional variation were employed.
Of the 2,870,695 inpatient separations and 1,803,307 same-day surgery separations during the study period, 359,972 and 64,541, respectively, were followed by home care. The rate of home care use per 100 separations was 12.5 for inpatients and 3.6 for same-day surgery patients. There was a a 3.5-fold regional variation in the rates of home care use following inpatient care and a 7-fold variation in rates of use following same-day surgery. Additional home care funding to attain calculated target rates was estimated to be $48.9 million (30% of expenditures for patients recently discharged from hospital over the study period). For a 20% increase in service provision it was estimated that an additional injection of $42.2 million is required.
The wide regional variations in rates of home care use highlight the importance of modifying home care funding to ensure that all residents of Ontario have equal access to services. To achieve this our estimates suggest that a substantial increase in home care funding is warranted.
尽管已有报道称许多医疗服务的使用存在地区差异,但对家庭护理实践的关注却很少。鉴于护理场所从医院急剧转向私人家庭,确定家庭护理实践在地理区域上的差异程度非常重要。
使用加拿大卫生信息研究所和安大略省家庭护理管理系统数据库的数据,评估1993年、1994年和1995财政年度住院护理和同日手术后家庭护理使用率的地区差异。采用了各种地区差异衡量指标。
在研究期间的2,870,695例住院出院病例和1,803,307例同日手术出院病例中,分别有359,972例和64,541例随后接受了家庭护理。每100例出院病例的家庭护理使用率,住院患者为12.5,同日手术患者为3.6。住院护理后家庭护理使用率存在3.5倍的地区差异,同日手术后使用率存在7倍的差异。为达到计算出的目标使用率而额外提供的家庭护理资金估计为4890万美元(占研究期间近期出院患者支出的30%)。若服务提供量增加20%,估计还需要额外注入4220万美元。
家庭护理使用率的广泛地区差异凸显了调整家庭护理资金以确保安大略省所有居民都能平等获得服务的重要性。为实现这一目标,我们的估计表明有必要大幅增加家庭护理资金。