Frazer C, Emans S J, Goodman E, Luoni M, Bravender T, Knight J
Division of General Pediatrics, Children's Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Mass 02115, USA.
Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 1999 Nov;153(11):1190-4. doi: 10.1001/archpedi.153.11.1190.
To determine the teaching methods, materials currently used, and unmet needs for teaching developmental-behavioral pediatrics (DBP) at pediatric training programs in the United States.
Cross-sectional survey of US pediatric residency training programs. The survey questionnaire consisted of 3 instruments: a program director survey, a developmental-behavioral pediatrics survey, and an adolescent medicine survey.
Survey packets were mailed in January 1997 to 211 programs identified by mailing labels from the Association of Pediatric Program Directors.
Data from 148 programs (70%) completing both the DBP survey and program director survey were analyzed. Ninety-five percent of programs reported a block rotation, and 95% of those stated that the rotation was mandatory. Eighty-seven percent had a formal curriculum. Most programs reported using articles, lecture outlines, and precepting for teaching DBP. Few programs used standardized case-based or computerized materials. Most programs, however, indicated a desire for these materials. Few programs felt that 4 topics were covered adequately: adoption (12%), violence (24%), substance use (28%), and conduct problems (41%). Programs that perceived that they covered these topics adequately were more likely to use written cases as part of their curriculum (Mann-Whitney test, 1373.5; P=.04). Barriers to teaching included lack of adequate faculty, time, money, and curricular resources.
Pediatric residency programs have made significant gains in mandatory DBP training. However, many programs report a lack of adequate faculty, teaching materials, and methods. Responding programs indicated an interest in case-based materials. This approach may represent an alternative and underutilized resource for teaching DBP.
确定美国儿科培训项目中目前用于发育行为儿科学(DBP)教学的方法、材料以及未满足的需求。
对美国儿科住院医师培训项目进行横断面调查。调查问卷由3种工具组成:项目主任调查问卷、发育行为儿科学调查问卷和青少年医学调查问卷。
1997年1月,调查问卷包被邮寄给通过儿科项目主任协会邮寄标签确定的211个项目。
对148个(70%)同时完成DBP调查问卷和项目主任调查问卷的项目的数据进行了分析。95%的项目报告有集中轮转,其中95%表示该轮转是强制性的。87%的项目有正式课程。大多数项目报告使用文章、讲座大纲和带教进行DBP教学。很少有项目使用标准化的基于案例或计算机化的材料。然而,大多数项目表示需要这些材料。很少有项目认为4个主题得到了充分涵盖:收养(12%)、暴力(24%)、物质使用(28%)和行为问题(41%)。认为充分涵盖这些主题的项目更有可能将书面案例作为其课程的一部分(曼-惠特尼检验,1373.5;P = 0.04)。教学障碍包括缺乏足够的教员、时间、资金和课程资源。
儿科住院医师项目在强制性DBP培训方面取得了显著进展。然而,许多项目报告称缺乏足够的教员、教材和教学方法。回复的项目表示对基于案例的材料感兴趣。这种方法可能是DBP教学中一种未充分利用的替代资源。