Bussink J, Kaanders J H, Van der Kogel A J
Institute of Radiotherapy, University of Nijmegen, The Netherlands.
Acta Oncol. 1999;38(7):875-82. doi: 10.1080/028418699432563.
Experimental studies have shown an almost 2-fold increase in effectiveness if accelerated radiotherapy combined with carbogen and nicotinamide (ARCON) was compared with standard radiotherapy. This combination was chosen in order to overcome repopulation of clonogens during radiotherapy and to minimize tumour hypoxia. Analysis of microenvironmental parameters is required to identify tumours that can benefit from these new treatment approaches. In this study 124 patients with stage III or IV head and neck squamous cell carcinomas received ARCON treatment. Vascular architecture, perfusion, proliferation and oxygenation were studied in two human laryngeal squamous cell carcinoma xenograft lines and the effects of carbogen and nicotinamide were analysed. Loco-regional control for stage III-IV larynx carcinomas was 85%, for hypopharynx carcinomas 50% and for oral cavity and oropharynx carcinomas 65%. In the experimental studies, carbogen treatment resulted in one tumour line in a decrease of blood perfusion, which was reversed if nicotinamide was added. The other tumour line showed no perfusion changes after carbogen or nicotinamide treatment. Both tumour lines showed a drastic reduction of hypoxia after carbogen breathing only or carbogen breathing plus nicotinamide. The ARCON schedule results in high loco-regional tumour control rates. Analysis of tumour microenvironmental parameters showed differences in response to carbogen and nicotinamide between different tumour lines of similar histology and site of origin. This indicates that it may be advantageous to base the selection of patients for oxygenation modifying treatment on microenvironmental tumour characteristics.
实验研究表明,如果将加速放疗联合卡波金和烟酰胺(ARCON)与标准放疗相比较,其有效性几乎可提高两倍。选择这种联合治疗是为了克服放疗期间克隆原细胞的再增殖,并使肿瘤缺氧程度降至最低。需要对微环境参数进行分析,以确定哪些肿瘤能从这些新的治疗方法中获益。在本研究中,124例III期或IV期头颈部鳞状细胞癌患者接受了ARCON治疗。对两个人喉鳞状细胞癌异种移植瘤模型的血管结构、灌注、增殖和氧合情况进行了研究,并分析了卡波金和烟酰胺的作用。III-IV期喉癌的局部区域控制率为85%,下咽癌为50%,口腔和口咽癌为65%。在实验研究中,卡波金治疗使一个肿瘤模型的血流灌注减少,而加入烟酰胺后这种情况得到逆转。另一个肿瘤模型在接受卡波金或烟酰胺治疗后血流灌注未发生变化。仅给予卡波金吸入或卡波金吸入加烟酰胺后,两个肿瘤模型的缺氧情况均显著减轻。ARCON方案可实现较高的局部区域肿瘤控制率。对肿瘤微环境参数的分析显示,组织学和起源部位相似的不同肿瘤模型对卡波金和烟酰胺的反应存在差异。这表明,根据肿瘤微环境特征来选择适合进行氧合调节治疗的患者可能具有优势。