Jeremias A, Filardo S D, Whitbourn R J, Kernoff R S, Yeung A C, Fitzgerald P J, Yock P G
Division of Cardiovascular Medicine, Stanford University School of Medicine, Stanford, CA, USA.
Circulation. 2000 Jan 25;101(3):318-23. doi: 10.1161/01.cir.101.3.318.
Measurements of Doppler derived coronary flow reserve (CFR) and pressure derived fractional flow reserve (FFR) for coronary stenosis assessment depend on the induction of maximal hyperemia. Adenosine is the most widely used pharmacological agent but is expensive and poorly tolerated by some patients.
The objective of this study was to test the equivalency of adenosine 5'-triphosphate (ATP) to adenosine in their ability to cause maximal hyperemia as compared with the hyperemic response of complete coronary occlusion in 6 canines. Intracoronary administration of either ATP or adenosine resulted in a significant increase in CFR (2.79+/-0.64 and 2.22+/-0.7 for 10 microgram versus 4. 65+/-1.22 and 4.25+/-0.78 for 100 microgram for ATP and adenosine, respectively, P for trend <0.001) but not reaching the level of coronary occlusion (6.35+/-2.26). Additionally, FFR and CFR were measured in 35 different stenoses using ATP, adenosine, and coronary occlusion. There was an excellent linear correlation between ATP and adenosine for both CFR (R=0.934, P<0.001) and FFR (R=0.985, P<0.001). However, hyperemia with either ATP or adenosine was less than postocclusion hyperemia, resulting in significantly different reserve measurements (CFR: 1.93+/-0.66 and 2.08+/-0.81 versus 2.35+/-0.97, P<0.001; FFR: 0.62+/-0.24 and 0.63+/-0.23 versus 0.58+/-0.2, P<0.001).
利用多普勒测量冠状动脉血流储备(CFR)以及利用压力测量冠状动脉狭窄的血流储备分数(FFR)均依赖于最大充血的诱导。腺苷是最广泛使用的药物,但价格昂贵且部分患者耐受性差。
本研究的目的是在6只犬中,将三磷酸腺苷(ATP)与腺苷诱发最大充血的能力与完全冠状动脉闭塞后的充血反应进行等效性测试。冠状动脉内给予ATP或腺苷均可使CFR显著增加(10微克时,ATP和腺苷分别为2.79±0.64和2.22±0.7;100微克时分别为4.65±1.22和4.25±0.78,趋势P<0.001),但未达到冠状动脉闭塞时的水平(6.35±2.26)。此外,使用ATP、腺苷和冠状动脉闭塞在35处不同狭窄处测量了FFR和CFR。对于CFR(R=0.934,P<0.001)和FFR(R=0.985,P<0.001),ATP与腺苷之间均存在极好的线性相关性。然而,ATP或腺苷诱发的充血均小于闭塞后充血,导致储备测量值存在显著差异(CFR:1.93±0.66和2.08±0.81对比2.35±0.97,P<0.001;FFR:0.62±0.24和0.63±0.23对比0.58±0.2,P<0.001)。
1)ATP和腺苷剂量超过目前推荐的临床剂量会导致冠状动脉充血显著增加;2)ATP在CFR和FFR方面与腺苷等效;3)完全冠状动脉闭塞产生的充血反应优于任何一种药物,表明两种药物刺激均未达到最大充血。