You L, Yang C T, Jablons D M
Thoracic Oncology Laboratory, University of California, San Francisco 94143-1674, USA.
Cancer Res. 2000 Feb 15;60(4):1009-13.
p53 mutations and loss of heterozygosity (LOH) have been detected in >50% of lung cancers. Wild-type p53 can prevent replication of damaged DNA and promote apoptosis of cells with abnormal DNA. A human adenovirus, ONYX-015, which has a deletion in the E1B region, has shown tumor-specific cytolytic effect in tumor cells with nonfunctional p53 and antitumor efficacy that can be augmented by chemotherapeutic agents. A recent report from an independent group, however, indicates that wild-type p53 is necessary for the infection of this replicating virus, and it is in direct contradiction to previous observations of the ONYX group. In this study, we carried out cytopathic effect (CPE) assays using ONYX-015 on five human lung cancer cell lines with known p53 status. Two of these cell lines, NCI-H522 and NCI-H1703, have mutations and LOH in their p53 gene. Both lines were lysed in a dose-dependent manner and showed 100% cytolysis at a multiplicity of infection of 0.1. Two additional cell lines, NCI-H2347 and NCI-H838, both of which have wild-type p53 gene, showed near complete lysis at a multiplicity of infection of 1. We demonstrate here that the lung cancer cells with nonfunctional p53 are at least 10 times more sensitive to ONYX-015 cytolysis than the lung cancer cells with wild-type p53. In addition, standard chemotherapeutic agents (paclitaxol and cisplatin) showed a synergistic effect when combined with ONYX-015, and this effect was p53 mutant dependent. Furthermore, we tested the cytolytic effect of ONYX-015 on a panel (n = 7) of primary first-passage cultures made from freshly resected lung cancers. ONYX-015 lysed primary lung cancer cells in six of seven (86 %) primary cultures. Two of four primary cultures treated with chemotherapeutic agents had a synergistic effect with ONYX-015. Our data indicate that wild-type p53 is not required for the infection of this replicating virus, and also we demonstrate that ONYX-015 is effective alone and works synergistically with chemotherapeutic agents in lung cancer cell lines and primary cultures. This study suggests that ONYX-015 may be effective, especially in combination with conventional chemotherapy, in the treatment of patients with lung cancer.
在超过50%的肺癌中已检测到p53突变和杂合性缺失(LOH)。野生型p53可阻止受损DNA的复制,并促进DNA异常细胞的凋亡。一种人类腺病毒ONYX - 015,其E1B区域存在缺失,在p53功能缺失的肿瘤细胞中显示出肿瘤特异性溶细胞作用,且其抗肿瘤疗效可被化疗药物增强。然而,一个独立研究小组最近的报告表明,野生型p53对于这种复制型病毒的感染是必需的,这与ONYX小组之前的观察结果直接矛盾。在本研究中,我们使用ONYX - 015对五个已知p53状态的人肺癌细胞系进行了细胞病变效应(CPE)检测。其中两个细胞系NCI - H522和NCI - H1703,其p53基因存在突变和LOH。这两个细胞系均以剂量依赖性方式裂解,在感染复数为0.1时显示出100%的细胞溶解。另外两个细胞系NCI - H2347和NCI - H838,两者均具有野生型p53基因,在感染复数为1时显示出近乎完全的裂解。我们在此证明,p53功能缺失的肺癌细胞对ONYX - 015溶细胞作用的敏感性至少是具有野生型p53的肺癌细胞的10倍。此外,标准化疗药物(紫杉醇和顺铂)与ONYX - 015联合使用时显示出协同作用,且这种作用依赖于p53突变体。此外,我们测试了ONYX - 015对一组(n = 7)由新鲜切除的肺癌制成的原代首次传代培养物的溶细胞作用。ONYX - 015在七份原代培养物中的六份(86%)中裂解了原发性肺癌细胞。在四份接受化疗药物处理的原代培养物中,有两份与ONYX - 015产生了协同作用。我们的数据表明,这种复制型病毒的感染不需要野生型p53,并且我们还证明了ONYX - 015在肺癌细胞系和原代培养物中单独有效且与化疗药物协同作用。这项研究表明,ONYX - 015在肺癌患者的治疗中可能有效,尤其是与传统化疗联合使用时。