Jacobs B, Mercer A
School of Social Science and International Development, University of Wales, Swansea, UK.
Health Policy Plan. 1999 Dec;14(4):354-62. doi: 10.1093/heapol/14.4.354.
The demand for blood transfusion is high in sub-Saharan Africa because of the high prevalence of anaemia and pregnancy related complications, but the practice is estimated to account for 10% of HIV infections in some regions. The main response to this problem by the international donor community is to establish vertically implemented blood transfusion services producing suitable (safe) blood at a cost of US$25-40 per unit. However, the economic sustainability of such interventions is questionable and it is argued here that hospital-based blood transfusion services operating at a basic adequate level are sufficient for low-income African countries. The results of a project aimed at improving such services in Tanzania are presented. The main findings are: (1) the cost per suitable blood unit produced was US$12.4; (2) at an HIV test sensitivity of 93.5% during the study period, discounted financial benefits of the interventions exceeded costs by a factor of between 17.2 and 37.1; (3) the cost per undiscounted year of life saved by use of these interventions was US$2.7-2.8; and (4) safe blood transfusion practices can be assured at an annual cost of US$0.07 per capita. Recommendations are made to ensure safe blood transfusion practices at hospital-based blood banks in Tanzania.
由于贫血和妊娠相关并发症的高患病率,撒哈拉以南非洲地区对输血的需求很高,但据估计,在某些地区,这种做法占艾滋病毒感染的10%。国际捐助界对这一问题的主要应对措施是建立垂直实施的输血服务,以每单位25至40美元的成本生产合适(安全)的血液。然而,这种干预措施的经济可持续性值得怀疑,本文认为,对于低收入非洲国家来说,在基本充足水平上运作的医院输血服务就足够了。本文介绍了一个旨在改善坦桑尼亚此类服务的项目的结果。主要发现如下:(1)每生产一个合适血液单位的成本为12.4美元;(2)在研究期间艾滋病毒检测灵敏度为93.5%的情况下,干预措施的贴现后经济收益超过成本17.2至37.1倍;(3)使用这些干预措施每挽救一个未贴现生命年的成本为2.7至2.8美元;(4)以人均每年0.07美元的成本可以确保安全输血做法。本文提出了确保坦桑尼亚医院血库安全输血做法的建议。