Henderson-Smart D J, Steer P A
NSW Centre for Perinatal Health Services Research, Queen Elizabeth II Institute for Mothers and Infants, Building DO2, University of Sydney, Sydney, NSW, Australia, 2006.
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2000(2):CD000074. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD000074.
Recurrent apnea is common in preterm infants, particularly at very early gestational ages. These episodes of loss of effective breathing can lead to hypoxemia and bradycardia which may be severe enough to require resuscitation including use of positive pressure ventilation. Doxapram has been used to stimulate breathing and so prevent apnea and its consequences.
In preterm infants with recurrent apnea, does treatment with doxapram lead to a clinically important reduction in apnea and use of Intermittent positive airways pressure (IPPV), without clinically important side effects?
Searches were made of the Oxford Database of Perinatal trials, the Cochrane Collaboration Clinical Trials Register, MEDLINE (using text words 'doxapram', 'apnea or apnoea' and Mesh term 'infant, premature') previous reviews including cross references, abstracts, conferences and symposia proceedings, expert informants, mainly in the English language. Also an expert informant's search in the Japanese language was made by Prof. Y. Ogawa in 1996.
All trials utilising random or quasi-random patient allocation, in which doxapram was used for the treatment of apnea in preterm infants were included.
Each author evaluated the papers for quality and inclusion criteria. Independent data extraction was carried out.
Only one trial, which randomized 11 infants to intravenous doxapram and 10 infants to placebo, was found. There were fewer treatment failures after 48 hours in the group of preterm infants treated with doxapram (4/11) compared with the group treated with placebo (8/10). The wide confidence intervals made this result non-significant [RR 0.45 (0.20, 1.05)]. Only one infant, who was from the placebo group, was given IPPV. Of the seven responders by 48 hours in the group of 11 who received doxapram, five failed to respond between 48 hours and seven days after commencement of therapy. This gives a late failure rate of 9/11, similar to the short term failure rate in the placebo group of 8/10. It is not possible to evaluate the late responses of all those in the placebo group since they crossed over to a treatment arm.
REVIEWER'S CONCLUSIONS: Although intravenous doxapram might reduce apnea within the first 48 hours of treatment, there are insufficient data to evaluate the precision of this result or to assess potential adverse effects. No longterm outcomes have been measured. Further studies are needed to determine the role of this treatment in clinical practice.
反复呼吸暂停在早产儿中很常见,尤其是在极早孕期。这些有效呼吸丧失的发作可导致低氧血症和心动过缓,严重时可能需要进行复苏,包括使用正压通气。多沙普仑已被用于刺激呼吸,从而预防呼吸暂停及其后果。
对于反复呼吸暂停的早产儿,多沙普仑治疗能否在无重要临床副作用的情况下,使呼吸暂停及间歇性正压通气(IPPV)的使用在临床上得到显著减少?
检索了牛津围产期试验数据库、Cochrane协作网临床试验注册库、MEDLINE(使用关键词“多沙普仑”、“呼吸暂停”及医学主题词“婴儿,早产”),以及以往的综述,包括交叉参考文献、摘要、会议及研讨会论文集,还咨询了专家,主要使用英文资料。1996年小川洋教授还进行了一次日语专家咨询检索。
纳入所有采用随机或半随机患者分配方法,使用多沙普仑治疗早产儿呼吸暂停的试验。
每位作者评估论文的质量及纳入标准。进行独立的数据提取。
仅找到一项试验,该试验将11名婴儿随机分为静脉注射多沙普仑组和10名婴儿为安慰剂组。与安慰剂组(8/10)相比,多沙普仑治疗的早产儿组在48小时后治疗失败的情况较少(4/11)。宽泛的置信区间使该结果无统计学意义[相对危险度0.45(0.20,1.05)]。仅1名来自安慰剂组的婴儿接受了IPPV。在接受多沙普仑治疗的11名婴儿中,48小时时有7名有反应者,其中5名在治疗开始后48小时至7天之间无反应。这使得后期失败率为9/11,与安慰剂组的短期失败率8/10相似。由于安慰剂组的所有婴儿都交叉到了治疗组,所以无法评估安慰剂组所有人的后期反应。
尽管静脉注射多沙普仑可能在治疗的前48小时内减少呼吸暂停,但没有足够的数据来评估该结果的准确性或评估潜在的不良反应。尚未测量长期结局。需要进一步研究以确定该治疗方法在临床实践中的作用。