Carreras E, Tomás J F, Sanz G, Iriondo A, Boqué C, López J, Cabrera R, Sureda A, de Soria V G, Sierra J, Sanz M A, Torres A
BMT Section, Hematology Department, Hospital Clínic, Villarroel 170, 08036 Barcelona, Spain.
Haematologica. 2000 May;85(5):530-8.
To analyze the results of unrelated bone marrow transplantation (UDBMT) as treatment for chronic myeloid leukemia (CML) in Spain.
Eighty-seven consecutive UDBMT performed in 9 centers between October 1989 and February 1998 were evaluated. This represents more than 95% of UDBMT for CML performed in adult transplant centers in Spain during this period. The patients' median age was 31.5 years (range, 12-49). The median interval from CML diagnosis to UDBMT was 30 months (range, 3-160). Seventy-nine percent of transplants were performed during the first chronic phase (1CP).
Actuarial probability of survival and disease-free survival at 4 years for the whole series was 24% (95% confidence interval [CI]: 14%-34%) and 20% (CI: 10%-30%), respectively. The cumulative incidence of relapse and transplant-related mortality (TRM) was 7% (CI: 4%-10%) and 71% (CI: 60%-82%), respectively. The main causes of death were graft failure (n=7), infection (n=23), and graft-versus-host disease (GvHD) (n=25). The actuarial probability of acute GvHD grade II-IV and grade III-IV was 56% (CI:46%-66%) and 36% (CI: 26%-36%), respectively. The cumulative incidence of extensive chronic GvHD was 18% (CI: 9%-27%). Univariate analyses showed that the pre-transplant factor with the highest influence on survival was disease status at transplant (30% in 1CP vs. 0% in advanced phases; p=0.0001). Other pre-transplant factors influencing survival among patients in 1CP were: patient's age (older than 30 years 11% vs. 48%), interval diagnosis-transplantation (longer than 2 years 17% vs. 55%), donor type (HLA, B, DRB1 identical 32% vs. 25%), CMV serologic status (donor and recipient negative 63% vs. 24%), year of transplantation (before 1995 19% vs. 40%), and conditioning regimen (cyclophosphamide plus total body radiation 40% vs. 16%). The main risk factors had a cumulative effect on survival. Thus, probability of survival ranged from 66% (CI: 39%-93%) in patients in 1CP, under 40 years of age, transplanted from an HLA, A, B, DRB1 identical donor during the first two years after diagnosis, to 0% in those with three or more risk factors.
This experience shows that UDBMT used to have a high TRM that has progressively decreased along the years. At the present time, the results are encouraging, particularly when UDBMT is performed under favorable conditions.
分析西班牙无关供者骨髓移植(UDBMT)治疗慢性髓性白血病(CML)的结果。
对1989年10月至1998年2月期间在9个中心进行的87例连续UDBMT进行评估。这占该时期西班牙成人移植中心进行的CML的UDBMT的95%以上。患者的中位年龄为31.5岁(范围12 - 49岁)。从CML诊断到UDBMT的中位间隔时间为30个月(范围3 - 160个月)。79%的移植在慢性期1(1CP)进行。
整个系列4年时的生存精算概率和无病生存精算概率分别为24%(95%置信区间[CI]:14% - 34%)和20%(CI:10% - 30%)。复发和移植相关死亡率(TRM)的累积发生率分别为7%(CI:4% - 10%)和71%(CI:60% - 82%)。主要死亡原因是移植物失败(n = 7)、感染(n = 23)和移植物抗宿主病(GvHD)(n = 25)。急性II - IV级和III - IV级GvHD的精算概率分别为56%(CI:46% - 66%)和36%(CI:26% - 36%)。广泛性慢性GvHD的累积发生率为18%(CI:9% - 27%)。单因素分析显示,对生存影响最大的移植前因素是移植时的疾病状态(1CP时为30%,晚期为0%;p = 0.0001)。影响1CP患者生存的其他移植前因素包括:患者年龄(大于30岁为11%对48%)、诊断 - 移植间隔时间(大于2年为17%对55%)、供者类型(HLA、B、DRB1相合为32%对25%)、CMV血清学状态(供者和受者均为阴性为63%对24%)、移植年份(1995年前为19%对40%)以及预处理方案(环磷酰胺加全身照射为40%对16%)。主要危险因素对生存有累积影响。因此,生存概率范围从诊断后前两年内由HLA、A、B、DRB1相合供者移植的40岁以下1CP患者的66%(CI:39% - 93%)到有三个或更多危险因素患者的0%。
该经验表明,UDBMT过去TRM较高,但多年来已逐渐降低。目前,结果令人鼓舞,尤其是在有利条件下进行UDBMT时。