Newton S A, Knottenbelt D C, Eldridge P R
Department of Animal Husbandry and Veterinary Clinical Sciences, University of Liverpool, South Wirral, UK.
Equine Vet J. 2000 May;32(3):208-16. doi: 10.2746/042516400776563617.
Twenty mature horses with typical headshaking of 2 week-7 year duration were studied. Clinical examinations included radiography of the head and nasopharyngeal endoscopy. All were assessed at rest and at exercise, both before and after fitting an occlusive nasal mask, application of tinted contact lenses and the perineural anaesthesia of the infraorbital and posterior ethmoidal branches of the trigeminal nerve. Infraorbital anaesthesia had no effect in 6/7 cases but 11/17 (65%) cases showed a 90-100% improvement following posterior ethmoidal nerve anaesthesia. Tinted contact lenses had no apparent long-term benefit, although 2 cases showed a transient improvement. We found no other evidence to suggest a photic aetiology in the current series of cases. Treatment regimens based on the results of the diagnostic investigative methods included sclerosis of the posterior ethmoidal branch of the trigeminal nerve. This was effective in some cases but the benefits were temporary. Cyproheptadine alone was ineffective but the addition of carbamazepine resulted in 80-100% improvement in 80% of cases. Carbemazepine alone was effective in 88% of cases but results were unpredictable at predefined dose rates. The positive response to carbamazepine, combined with the clinical features is consistent with involvement of the trigeminal nerve, particularly the more proximal branches such as the posterior ethmoidal nerve. Headshaking has some clinical features in common with trigeminal neuralgia in humans. As a result of the findings detailed in this paper, we conclude that a trigeminal neuritis or neuralgia may be the basis of the underlying aetiopathology of equine headshaking. Initial observations of the positive response of headshakers to carbamazepine therapy is encouraging. However, future studies will include a more detailed investigation of dosages, duration of effectiveness (in some cases it appears short-lived) and other effects. In practice there is a realistic possibility of controlling but not curing headshaking with carbamazepine therapy at the present time. Other future investigations will include details of the functional anatomy of the trigeminal nerve and the role of the P2 myelin protein in headshaking and other neurological disease.
对20匹患有持续2周 - 7年典型晃头症状的成年马进行了研究。临床检查包括头部X光摄影和鼻咽部内窥镜检查。所有马匹在佩戴闭塞性鼻罩、应用有色隐形眼镜以及对三叉神经的眶下分支和筛后分支进行神经周围麻醉之前和之后,均在休息和运动状态下进行评估。眶下神经麻醉在6/7的病例中无效,但11/17(65%)的病例在筛后神经麻醉后有90 - 100%的改善。有色隐形眼镜没有明显的长期益处,尽管有2例显示有短暂改善。在当前系列病例中,我们没有发现其他证据表明存在光病因。基于诊断性检查方法结果的治疗方案包括三叉神经筛后分支的硬化治疗。这在一些病例中有效,但益处是暂时的。单独使用赛庚啶无效,但添加卡马西平后80%的病例有80 - 100%的改善。单独使用卡马西平在88%的病例中有效,但在预定义剂量率下结果不可预测。对卡马西平的阳性反应以及临床特征与三叉神经受累一致,特别是更靠近近端的分支,如筛后神经。马的晃头在某些临床特征上与人类的三叉神经痛相似。基于本文详细描述的研究结果,我们得出结论,三叉神经炎或神经痛可能是马晃头潜在病因病理学的基础。晃头马匹对卡马西平治疗的阳性反应的初步观察结果令人鼓舞。然而,未来的研究将包括对剂量、有效性持续时间(在某些情况下似乎是短暂的)和其他影响进行更详细的调查。在实践中,目前使用卡马西平治疗有可能控制但无法治愈晃头症状。未来的其他研究将包括三叉神经功能解剖学的细节以及P2髓磷脂蛋白在晃头和其他神经系统疾病中的作用。
Equine Vet J. 1995-7
J Am Vet Med Assoc. 2001-8-1
Vet Radiol Ultrasound. 2019-9
Animals (Basel). 2024-3-13
Animals (Basel). 2022-5-27