Brion L P, Primhak R A, Ambrosio-Perez I
Pediatrics, Division of Neonatology, Albert Einstein College of Medicine and Montefiore Medical Center, Weiler Hospital Room 725, 1825 Eastchester Road, Bronx, NY 10461, USA.
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2000(3):CD001817. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD001817.
The aim of this review is to assess the risks and benefits of diuretics acting on distal segments of the renal tubule (distal diuretics) in preterm infants with or developing chronic lung disease (CLD). Primary objectives are to assess changes in need for oxygen or ventilatory support and effects on long-term outcome, and secondary objectives are to assess changes in pulmonary mechanics and potential complications of therapy.
We used the standard method of the Cochrane Neonatal Review Group. We used the following keywords: ¿
We included in this analysis trials in which preterm infants with or developing CLD and at least five days of age were all randomly allocated to receive a distal diuretic (i.e., a diuretic acting on the distal renal tubule). Eligible studies needed to assess at least one of the outcome variables defined a priori for this systematic review. Primary outcome variables included changes in need for respiratory support and oxygen supplementation, mortality, bronchopulmonary dysplasia (BPD), death or BPD, chronic lung disease at 36 weeks of postconceptional age (gestational age + postnatal age), length of stay, and number of rehospitalizations during the first year of life. Secondary outcome variables included pulmonary mechanics and potential complications of therapy.
We used the standard method for the Cochrane Collaboration which is described in the Cochrane Collaboration Handbook. Two investigators extracted, assessed and coded separately all data for each study, using a form that was designed specifically for this review. Any disagreement was resolved by discussion. We combined parallel and cross-over trials and, whenever possible, transformed baseline and final outcome data measured on a continuous scale into change scores using Follmann's formula.
Of six studies fulfilling entry criteria, most focused on pathophysiological parameters and did not assess effects on important clinical outcomes defined in this review, or the potential complications of diuretic therapy. In preterm infants > 3 weeks of age with CLD, a four-week treatment with thiazide and spironolactone improved lung compliance and reduced the need for furosemide. Thiazide and spironolactone decreased the risk of death and tended to decrease the risk for lack of extubation after 8 weeks in intubated infants who did not have access to corticosteroids, bronchodilators or aminophylline. However, there is little or no evidence to support any benefit of diuretic administration on need for ventilatory support, length of hospital stay, or long-term outcome in patients receiving current therapy. There is no evidence to support the hypothesis that adding spironolactone to thiazide or that adding metolazone to furosemide improves the outcome of preterm infants with CLD.
REVIEWER'S CONCLUSIONS: In preterm infants > 3 weeks of age with CLD, acute and chronic administration of distal diuretics improve pulmonary mechanics. Studies are needed to assess (1) whether thiazide administration improves mortality, duration of oxygen dependency, ventilator dependency, length of hospital stay and long-term outcome in patients exposed to corticosteroids and bronchodilators (2) whether adding spironolactone to thiazides or adding metolazone to furosemide has any beneficial effect.
本综述旨在评估作用于肾小管远端节段的利尿剂(远端利尿剂)对患有或正在发展为慢性肺病(CLD)的早产儿的风险和益处。主要目的是评估对氧气或通气支持需求的变化以及对长期预后的影响,次要目的是评估肺力学的变化以及治疗的潜在并发症。
我们采用了Cochrane新生儿综述小组的标准方法。我们使用了以下关键词:“<支气管肺发育不良>或<慢性肺病>”以及“<展开利尿剂>”,限定为“<人类>”且限定为“<婴儿,新生儿>”或“<婴儿>”。我们检索了Medline(1966 - 1998年)、Embase(1974 - 1998年)以及Cochrane图书馆(1999年第2期)中的Cochrane对照试验注册库(CCTR)。此外,我们还手工检索了美国和欧洲国家及国际学会的几本摘要书籍。
我们纳入本分析的试验为,患有或正在发展为CLD且至少5日龄的早产儿被随机分配接受远端利尿剂(即作用于远端肾小管的利尿剂)治疗。符合条件的研究需要评估本系统综述预先定义的至少一个结局变量。主要结局变量包括呼吸支持和氧补充需求的变化、死亡率、支气管肺发育不良(BPD)、死亡或BPD、孕龄36周时的慢性肺病(孕龄 + 出生后年龄)、住院时间以及生命第一年的再次住院次数。次要结局变量包括肺力学和治疗的潜在并发症。
我们采用了Cochrane协作网的标准方法,该方法在《Cochrane协作网手册》中有描述。两名研究人员分别提取、评估并编码每项研究的所有数据,使用专门为此综述设计的表格。任何分歧都通过讨论解决。我们合并了平行试验和交叉试验,并尽可能使用福尔曼公式将以连续尺度测量的基线和最终结局数据转换为变化分数。
在符合纳入标准的6项研究中,大多数研究关注病理生理参数,未评估对本综述中定义的重要临床结局的影响或利尿剂治疗的潜在并发症。在年龄大于3周的患有CLD的早产儿中,噻嗪类和螺内酯四周的治疗可改善肺顺应性并减少对速尿的需求。在无法使用皮质类固醇、支气管扩张剂或氨茶碱的插管婴儿中,噻嗪类和螺内酯降低了死亡风险,并倾向于降低8周后不能拔管的风险。然而,几乎没有证据支持利尿剂给药对接受当前治疗的患者的通气支持需求、住院时间或长期预后有任何益处。没有证据支持将螺内酯添加到噻嗪类药物中或把美托拉宗添加到速尿中可改善患有CLD的早产儿预后的假设。
在年龄大于3周的患有CLD的早产儿中,急性和慢性给予远端利尿剂可改善肺力学。需要进行研究以评估:(1)噻嗪类药物给药是否能改善接受皮质类固醇和支气管扩张剂治疗患者的死亡率、氧依赖持续时间、呼吸机依赖、住院时间和长期预后;(2)将螺内酯添加到噻嗪类药物中或把美托拉宗添加到速尿中是否有任何有益效果。