Reyes H, Kauffmann R, Andresen M
Rev Med Chil. 2000 Apr;128(4):363-6.
Multiauthorship shows an increasing trend in biomedical and other scientific journals. A main concern for editors, reviewers and readers is to find out whether all individuals enlisted as authors actually fulfill criteria for authorship as defined in the document "Uniform Requirements for Manuscripts Submitted to Biomedical Journals". Revista Médica de Chile is addressing this relevant topic with a combined strategy: (1) A retrospective analysis of the manuscripts published in the recent decades in the Revista will quantify and illustrate the local trend in multiauthorship; (2) A "Statement of accountability": signed by all authors in manuscripts submitted to the Revista, is in use since 1997; and (3) A new form of this "Statement of accountability" requests all authors to identify their personal involvement in the work represented by the manuscript. This information will be available to every person participating in the editorial assessment of the manuscript (editors and external reviewers) but during a trial period of six months authors will be allowed to object the publication of this data, stating the reasons for this objection. After six months the editors will evaluate the information collected and the self-declared role of every author enlisted. The terms "Author" and "Main author" will continue being used to designate participants because "contributor" (replacement alternative proposed by Rennie et al., currently in use by several leading general medical journals) has a different main meaning in Spanish than in English and it might have a negative effect.
多作者情况在生物医学及其他科学期刊中呈上升趋势。编辑、审稿人和读者主要关心的是确定所有列为作者的个人是否真正符合《向生物医学期刊投稿的统一要求》文件中规定的作者标准。《智利医学杂志》正通过一项综合策略来处理这一相关主题:(1)对该杂志近几十年来发表的稿件进行回顾性分析,将量化并说明多作者情况的本地趋势;(2)自1997年起,使用一种由提交给该杂志的稿件的所有作者签署的“责任声明”;(3)这种“责任声明”的新形式要求所有作者明确其个人在稿件所代表的工作中的参与情况。此信息将提供给参与稿件编辑评估的每个人(编辑和外部审稿人),但在为期六个月的试行期内,作者可对该数据的发表提出异议,并说明异议理由。六个月后,编辑将评估所收集的信息以及每个所列作者自行声明的角色。将继续使用“作者”和“主要作者”这两个术语来指称参与者,因为“贡献者”(Rennie等人提议的替代用词,目前几家主要的综合医学期刊正在使用)在西班牙语中的主要含义与英语不同,可能会产生负面影响。