Miklowitz D J, Simoneau T L, George E L, Richards J A, Kalbag A, Sachs-Ericsson N, Suddath R
Department of Psychology, University of Colorado, Boulder 80309-0345, USA.
Biol Psychiatry. 2000 Sep 15;48(6):582-92. doi: 10.1016/s0006-3223(00)00931-8.
Few studies have examined the combined effects of psychosocial treatment and pharmacotherapy for bipolar disorder. This study used a randomized, controlled design to examine a 9-month, manual-based program of family-focused psychoeducational treatment (FFT).
Bipolar patients (N = 101) were recruited shortly after an illness episode and randomly assigned to 21 sessions of FFT (n = 31) or to a comparison treatment involving two family education sessions and follow-up crisis management (CM; n = 70). Both treatments were delivered over 9 months; patients were simultaneously maintained on mood stabilizing medications. Patients were evaluated every 3 months for 1 year as to relapse status, symptom severity, and medication compliance.
Patients assigned to FFT had fewer relapses and longer delays before relapses during the study year than did patients in CM. Patients in FFT also showed greater improvements in depressive (but not manic) symptoms. The most dramatic improvements were among FFT patients whose families were high in expressed emotion. The efficacy of FFT could not be explained by differences among patients in medication regimes or compliance.
Family-focused psychoeducational treatment appears to be an efficacious adjunct to pharmacotherapy for bipolar disorder. Future studies should evaluate family treatment against other forms of psychotherapy matched in amount of therapist-patient contact.
很少有研究探讨心理社会治疗与药物治疗相结合对双相情感障碍的效果。本研究采用随机对照设计,以检验一项为期9个月、基于手册的以家庭为中心的心理教育治疗(FFT)项目。
双相情感障碍患者(N = 101)在发病后不久被招募,并随机分配接受21次FFT治疗(n = 31)或接受包括两次家庭教育课程和后续危机管理(CM;n = 70)的对照治疗。两种治疗均持续9个月;患者同时维持使用心境稳定剂。在1年时间里,每3个月对患者的复发状态、症状严重程度和药物依从性进行评估。
在研究年度内,接受FFT治疗的患者比接受CM治疗的患者复发次数更少,复发前的延迟时间更长。接受FFT治疗的患者在抑郁(而非躁狂)症状方面也有更大改善。最显著的改善出现在那些家庭情感表达程度高的接受FFT治疗的患者中。FFT的疗效无法用患者药物治疗方案或依从性的差异来解释。
以家庭为中心的心理教育治疗似乎是双相情感障碍药物治疗的一种有效辅助手段。未来的研究应该将家庭治疗与其他形式的心理治疗进行对照评估,这些心理治疗在治疗师与患者接触时间上应相当。