Robling S A, Paykel E S, Dunn V J, Abbott R, Katona C
Department of Psychiatry, University of Cambridge.
Psychol Med. 2000 Nov;30(6):1263-71. doi: 10.1017/s0033291799003025.
Although there have been many follow-up studies of severe puerperal psychiatric illness, few have been very long-term.
Sixty-four subjects from 85 (75.3%) in an unselected sample of women admitted to a psychiatric hospital within 6 months of childbirth were successfully followed up a mean of 23 years (range 17-28) later. Most subjects were interviewed in detail, with further information obtained from general practice and hospital records. Data included subsequent illnesses and diagnoses, subsequent childbirth, longitudinal social function, current symptoms and social function.
Seventy-five per cent of subjects had further psychiatric illnesses, most of them unrelated to childbirth, and 37% had at least three subsequent episodes. The risk of puerperal psychiatric illness was 29% in subsequent pregnancies. At outcome interview the majority of subjects were well, with satisfactory social adjustment. Diagnoses in subsequent psychiatric illnesses showed considerable consistency with index diagnoses, with some shift to bipolar disorder. Further illnesses were less likely to occur where the index illness occurred with first child, onset was within 1 month of delivery, and where the index diagnosis was unipolar depression.
There is a high risk of subsequent non-puerperal recurrences following severe puerperal psychotic illness, showing considerable diagnostic consistency with the index episode, but with good functional outcome. Puerperal illnesses showed strong continuities with non-puerperal illnesses in these women.
尽管已有许多关于严重产褥期精神疾病的随访研究,但很少有长期研究。
在分娩后6个月内入住精神病院的未筛选女性样本中,85名女性中有64名(75.3%)成功随访,平均随访时间为23年(范围17 - 28年)。大多数受试者接受了详细访谈,并从全科医疗和医院记录中获取了进一步信息。数据包括后续疾病及诊断、后续分娩情况、纵向社会功能、当前症状及社会功能。
75%的受试者患有进一步的精神疾病,其中大多数与分娩无关,37%至少有三次后续发作。后续妊娠中产褥期精神疾病的风险为29%。在结局访谈时,大多数受试者情况良好,社会适应令人满意。后续精神疾病的诊断与首次诊断显示出相当的一致性,有一些向双相情感障碍的转变。如果首次疾病发生在第一个孩子出生时、发病在分娩后1个月内且首次诊断为单相抑郁,则发生进一步疾病的可能性较小。
严重产褥期精神病性疾病后发生后续非产褥期复发的风险很高,与首次发作显示出相当的诊断一致性,但功能结局良好。在这些女性中,产褥期疾病与非产褥期疾病表现出很强的连续性。