Saunderson P, Gebre S, Desta K, Byass P, Lockwood D N
School of Community Health Science, Nottingham University, UK.
Lepr Rev. 2000 Sep;71(3):285-308. doi: 10.5935/0305-7518.20000033.
The ALERT MDT Field Evaluation Study (AMFES) began in 1988 and followed patients prospectively for up to 10 years after release from treatment (RFT). This paper presents the findings from this cohort with regard to neuropathy and nerve damage. Five hundred and ninety-four new cases of leprosy are included in the study, 300 multibacillary (MB) and 294 paucibacillary (PB) cases. Fifty-five percent of patients had some degree of impairment at diagnosis and a further 73 (12%) developed new nerve function impairment (NFI) after starting multiple drug therapy (MDT). The overall incidence rate for neuropathy was 39 episodes per 100 PYAR in the first year after diagnosis, gradually declining to 12 episodes per 100 PYAR in the sixth year. In those patients without impairment at diagnosis, the incidence rate of neuropathy was 25 episodes per 100 PYAR for MB cases and 11 per 100 PYAR for PB cases in the first year; in 33% of MB cases whose first episode of neuropathy occurred after diagnosis, that first episode took place after the first year, or after the normal period of treatment with MDT. Seventy-three patients with neuropathy developing after diagnosis are reported more fully: 34 (47%) had only one nerve involved and of these 25 (73%) had a single, acute episode of neuropathy. Nine (27%) had further episodes. Thirty-nine (53%) had more than one nerve involved and of these 16 (41%) had a single, acute episode, while 23 (59%) had further episodes. The terms 'chronic' and 'recurrent' neuropathy are defined and used to describe the pattern of neuropathy in those with repeated attacks. In patients with no impairment at the start of the study, treatment with steroids resulted in full recovery in 88% of nerves with acute neuropathy but only 51% of those with chronic or recurrent neuropathy. The median time to full recovery from acute neuropathy was approximately 6 months, but in a few cases recovery occurred gradually over 2-3 years. Severe neuropathy was less likely to be followed by a complete recovery than mild or moderate neuropathy. Forty-two percent of nerves with acute neuropathy that were not treated with steroids also fully recovered. In the group of patients who were thought to have old, permanent impairments at diagnosis, full recovery of nerve function occurred in 87/374 (23%) of the nerves involved. The overall outcome is illustrated by examining the average EHF score for groups of patients. Patients with no new neuropathy after diagnosis show a gradual improvement in their EHF score, while those with any episodes of neuropathy after diagnosis show a gradual deterioration after completion of MDT. Possible explanations for these findings are discussed. Risk factors for neuropathy, for chronic and recurrent neuropathy, and for a poor outcome 5 years after release from treatment, are examined. Impairment at diagnosis was the main risk factor for a poor outcome, accompanied by the occurrence of chronic/recurrent neuropathy or a reversal reaction.
警报多学科团队现场评估研究(AMFES)始于1988年,对患者进行前瞻性跟踪,直至治疗结束后长达10年。本文介绍了该队列中有关神经病变和神经损伤的研究结果。该研究纳入了594例麻风病新病例,其中300例为多菌型(MB),294例为少菌型(PB)。55%的患者在诊断时有一定程度的损伤,另有73例(12%)在开始联合化疗(MDT)后出现了新的神经功能损伤(NFI)。诊断后第一年神经病变的总发病率为每100人年39例,到第六年逐渐降至每100人年12例。在诊断时无损伤的患者中,MB病例第一年神经病变的发病率为每100人年25例,PB病例为每100人年11例;在33%的MB病例中,其首次神经病变发作发生在诊断后,且首次发作发生在第一年之后,或在MDT正常治疗期之后。对73例诊断后出现神经病变的患者进行了更全面的报告:34例(47%)仅累及一条神经,其中25例(73%)有单次急性神经病变发作。9例(27%)有进一步发作。39例(53%)累及多条神经,其中16例(41%)有单次急性发作,23例(59%)有进一步发作。定义了“慢性”和“复发性”神经病变这两个术语,并用于描述反复发作者的神经病变模式。在研究开始时无损伤的患者中,使用类固醇治疗使88%的急性神经病变神经完全恢复,但慢性或复发性神经病变神经仅51%完全恢复。急性神经病变完全恢复的中位时间约为6个月,但在少数情况下,恢复过程在2至3年中逐渐发生。与轻度或中度神经病变相比,严重神经病变完全恢复的可能性较小。42%未接受类固醇治疗的急性神经病变神经也完全恢复。在诊断时被认为有陈旧性永久性损伤的患者组中,87/374(23%)受累神经的神经功能完全恢复。通过检查患者组的平均EHF评分来说明总体结果。诊断后无新神经病变的患者EHF评分逐渐改善,而诊断后有任何神经病变发作的患者在MDT完成后EHF评分逐渐恶化。讨论了这些发现的可能解释。研究了神经病变、慢性和复发性神经病变以及治疗结束后5年预后不良的危险因素。诊断时的损伤是预后不良的主要危险因素,伴有慢性/复发性神经病变或逆转反应的发生。