Brenner D, Elliston C, Hall E, Berdon W
Center for Radiological Research, Columbia University, 630 W. 168th St., New York, NY 10032, USA.
AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2001 Feb;176(2):289-96. doi: 10.2214/ajr.176.2.1760289.
In light of the rapidly increasing frequency of pediatric CT examinations, the purpose of our study was to assess the lifetime cancer mortality risks attributable to radiation from pediatric CT.
Organ doses as a function of age-at-diagnosis were estimated for common CT examinations, and estimated attributable lifetime cancer mortality risks (per unit dose) for different organ sites were applied. Standard models that assume a linear extrapolation of risks from intermediate to low doses were applied. On the basis of current standard practice, the same exposures (milliampere-seconds) were assumed, independent of age.
The larger doses and increased lifetime radiation risks in children produce a sharp increase, relative to adults, in estimated risk from CT. Estimated lifetime cancer mortality risks attributable to the radiation exposure from a CT in a 1-year-old are 0.18% (abdominal) and 0.07% (head)-an order of magnitude higher than for adults-although those figures still represent a small increase in cancer mortality over the natrual background rate. In the United States, of approximately 600,000 abdominal and head CT examinations annually performed in children under the age of 15 years, a rough estimate is that 500 of these individuals might ultimately die from cancer attributable to the CT radiation.
The best available risk estimates suggest that pediatric CT will result in significantly increased lifetime radiation risk over adult CT, both because of the increased dose per milliampere-second, and the increased lifetime risk per unit dose. Lower milliampere-second settings can be used for children without significant loss of information. Although the risk-benefit balance is still strongly tilted toward benefit, because the frequency of pediatric CT examinations is rapidly increasing, estimates that quantitative lifetime radiation risks for children undergoing CT are not negligible may stimulate more active reduction of CT exposure settings in pediatric patients.
鉴于儿科CT检查的频率迅速增加,我们研究的目的是评估儿科CT辐射所致的终生癌症死亡风险。
针对常见的CT检查,估算了诊断时年龄的器官剂量,并应用了不同器官部位的估算终生归因癌症死亡风险(每单位剂量)。采用了假设风险从中等剂量到低剂量呈线性外推的标准模型。根据当前的标准做法,假设相同的照射量(毫安秒),与年龄无关。
与成人相比,儿童剂量较大且终生辐射风险增加,导致CT所致的估算风险急剧上升。1岁儿童因CT辐射暴露所致的终生癌症死亡风险估计为0.18%(腹部)和0.07%(头部),比成人高一个数量级,尽管这些数字仍表明癌症死亡率比自然背景率略有增加。在美国,每年对15岁以下儿童进行约60万次腹部和头部CT检查,粗略估计其中500人最终可能因CT辐射死于癌症。
现有最佳风险估计表明,儿科CT所致的终生辐射风险将显著高于成人CT,这既是因为每毫安秒的剂量增加,也是因为每单位剂量的终生风险增加。对于儿童,可以使用较低的毫安秒设置而不会显著损失信息。尽管风险效益平衡仍强烈倾向于效益,但由于儿科CT检查的频率迅速增加,对接受CT检查儿童的定量终生辐射风险估计不可忽略,这可能会促使更积极地降低儿科患者的CT照射设置。