Lindel K, Willett C G, Shellito P C, Ott M J, Clark J, Grossbard M, Ryan D, Ancukiewicz M
Department of Radiation Oncology, Massachusetts General Hospital, 55 Fruit Street, Boston, MA 02114, USA.
Radiother Oncol. 2001 Jan;58(1):83-7. doi: 10.1016/s0167-8140(00)00309-1.
To update and summarize the experience at the Massachusetts General Hospital of a treatment program of high-dose preoperative irradiation, surgical re-resection, and intraoperative radiation therapy (IORT) as a salvage treatment for patients with recurrent rectal or rectosigmoid carcinoma.
From June 1978 to February 1997, the records of 69 patients with locally recurrent rectal carcinomas or rectosigmoid carcinomas without metastases referred for consideration of IORT were reviewed. Forty-nine patients received IORT and local control and disease-free survival curves were calculated using the actuarial method of Kaplan-Meier.
The 5-year overall survival, local control and disease-free survival rates of 49 patients receiving IORT were 27, 35, and 20%, respectively. Thirty-four patients who underwent a macroscopic complete resection had a significantly better 5-year overall survival than the remaining 15 patients with gross residual disease (33 vs. 13%, P=0.05, log rank). For those patients, local control and disease-free survival rates were 46 and 27%, respectively. Patients with a microscopic complete resection had a superior 5-year overall survival than partially resected patients (40 vs. 14%, P=0.0001, log rank). Chemotherapy had no significant influence on overall or disease-free survival.
The current analysis shows the importance of a microscopic complete resection in a multi-modality approach with IORT for survival and local control. Salvage is rare for patients undergoing subtotal resection.
更新并总结麻省总医院采用高剂量术前放疗、手术再次切除及术中放疗(IORT)作为复发性直肠癌或直肠乙状结肠癌患者挽救性治疗方案的经验。
回顾1978年6月至1997年2月期间69例无远处转移的局部复发性直肠癌或直肠乙状结肠癌患者转诊接受IORT评估的记录。49例患者接受了IORT治疗,并采用Kaplan-Meier精算方法计算局部控制率和无病生存率曲线。
49例接受IORT治疗患者的5年总生存率、局部控制率和无病生存率分别为27%、35%和20%。34例实现肉眼下完全切除的患者5年总生存率显著高于其余15例有大体残留病灶的患者(33%对13%,P = 0.05,对数秩检验)。对于这些患者,局部控制率和无病生存率分别为46%和27%。实现显微镜下完全切除的患者5年总生存率高于部分切除的患者(40%对14%,P = 0.0001,对数秩检验)。化疗对总生存或无病生存无显著影响。
当前分析表明,在采用IORT的多模式治疗方法中,显微镜下完全切除对于生存和局部控制至关重要。接受次全切除的患者挽救性治疗的可能性很小。