Owens G M
Am J Manag Care. 2000 Sep;6(15 Suppl):S839-52; quiz S853-5.
Growth hormone (GH) therapy has an established record of efficacy in the treatment of children with proven GH deficiency. It has also shown benefit, including nongrowth-related benefit, in other nontraditional pediatric uses, but managed care plans hesitate to reimburse clinicians for such uses. In adults and in those individuals who are in transition from GH-deficient children to adults, GH deficiency is sometimes difficult to diagnose. In such cases, growth rate cannot be used to guide therapy and the outcomes measures are either "softer" (e.g., quality of life) or very long term (e.g., bone mineral density changes). Also, there are no long-term data to show GH treatment in adults affects the cardiovascular-associated morbidity and mortality from GH deficiency. However, several cardiovascular risk factors, such as hypercholesterolemia and abdominal adiposity, improve in GH-deficient adults who receive GH treatment. Clinicians and payers often appear at odds with each other over their primary goals for managing the various forms of GH deficiency. However, upon closer examination, both parties do share common treatment goals and strive to do the right clinical thing. Identifying the cost of treatment emphasizes the need for evidence-based medicine.
生长激素(GH)疗法在治疗已证实患有生长激素缺乏症的儿童方面有着确切的疗效记录。它在其他非传统儿科应用中也显示出益处,包括与生长无关的益处,但管理式医疗计划在为临床医生报销此类应用时犹豫不决。在成年人以及那些从生长激素缺乏的儿童过渡到成年人的个体中,生长激素缺乏有时难以诊断。在这种情况下,生长速率无法用于指导治疗,且结局指标要么是“较软性的”(如生活质量),要么是非常长期的(如骨矿物质密度变化)。此外,没有长期数据表明成人接受生长激素治疗会影响因生长激素缺乏导致的心血管相关发病率和死亡率。然而,一些心血管危险因素,如高胆固醇血症和腹部肥胖,在接受生长激素治疗的生长激素缺乏的成年人中有所改善。临床医生和支付方在管理各种形式的生长激素缺乏的主要目标上常常存在分歧。然而,经过仔细审视,双方确实有共同的治疗目标,并努力做出正确的临床决策。确定治疗成本凸显了循证医学的必要性。