McLucas B, Adler L, Perrella R
Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, University of California at Los Angeles, School of Medicine, USA.
J Am Coll Surg. 2001 Jan;192(1):95-105. doi: 10.1016/s1072-7515(00)00738-9.
Earlier studies demonstrated the efficacy of uterine fibroid embolization (UFE). We seek to demonstrate the success of the procedure in a community hospital setting, and we attempt to identify patients likely not to benefit from embolization, if possible, before the procedure.
The study followed all women treated with UFE for menorrhagia or postmenopausal bleeding at a community hospital between 1997 and 1999. Relief of symptoms, ultrasound changes, and complications were documented. Six months after the procedure, analysis was performed on ultrasound and interview data from patients who underwent UFE. A smaller number of patients has been followed for 12 months and were available for the analysis. We examined characteristics of patients and procedures performed in an attempt to identify likely failures of treatment. We calculated complication and failure rates based on the entire group of patients.
From 183 patients who applied for UFE, 16 were excluded because ofpathologic conditions found during preembolization evaluation; 167 women had an embolization, 163 were successfully embolized bilaterally, and 4 were embolized unilaterally because of technical failure. Eighty-eight percent of the patients (147 of 167 patients) reported an improvement or stabilization of symptoms 6 months after UFE. Forty-six patients followed for 12 months experienced myoma shrinkage of 37% (a significant shrinkage over 6 months, p < 0.001), and total uterine volume decreased 52%. Analysis of shrinkage data revealed no demographic or procedure variable associated with shrinkage. Six patients underwent hysterectomy (3.5%) after embolization, one as a result of postprocedure infection. Pain in the first 24 hours postprocedure affected almost all patients. Five percent of the patients passed submucous myomata after UFE; all these patients at risk were identified at preembolization hysteroscopy. Four patients experienced premature menopause after embolization early in the study. There were three criteria for failure, of which a patient had to meet only one: hysterectomy, < 10% shrinkage ofmyoma 6 months after UFE, or worsening symptoms after UFE. No variables of age or size of the uterus could be shown to predict failure. Patients who had undergone earlier pelvic surgery were more likely to fail UFE (p = 0.012).
Uterine fibroid embolization, an alternative treatment for myomas, offering low morbidity, can be performed in a community hospital setting. Eighty-eight percent of patients reported improvement or stabilization of symptoms. Total uterine volume decreased an average of 49% at 6 months after embolization. Shrinkage was unaffected by the size of the uterus, myoma, or patient characteristic before UFE. Longterm followup study reveals a significant continuing shrinkage of total uterine volume and myomata at 12 months. There has been no regrowth of fibroids. Earlier surgery was a factor predicting failure of UFE in our series. The risks to future fertility were small.
早期研究证实了子宫肌瘤栓塞术(UFE)的疗效。我们试图在社区医院环境中证明该手术的成功率,并尽可能在手术前识别可能无法从栓塞术中获益的患者。
该研究追踪了1997年至1999年间在一家社区医院接受UFE治疗月经过多或绝经后出血的所有女性。记录症状缓解情况、超声变化及并发症。手术后6个月,对接受UFE治疗的患者的超声和访谈数据进行分析。少数患者随访了12个月并可供分析。我们检查了患者的特征和所进行的手术,试图识别可能的治疗失败情况。我们根据整个患者群体计算了并发症和失败率。
在183名申请UFE的患者中,16名因栓塞术前评估中发现的病理状况而被排除;167名女性接受了栓塞术,163名双侧成功栓塞,4名因技术失败仅单侧栓塞。88%的患者(167名患者中的147名)报告UFE术后6个月症状改善或稳定。46名随访12个月的患者肌瘤缩小了37%(6个月内显著缩小,p<0.001),子宫总体积减少了52%。对缩小数据的分析显示,没有与缩小相关的人口统计学或手术变量。6名患者在栓塞术后接受了子宫切除术(3.5%),其中1名是由于术后感染。术后头24小时的疼痛几乎影响了所有患者。5%的患者在UFE术后排出黏膜下肌瘤;所有这些有风险的患者在栓塞术前宫腔镜检查时已被识别。在研究早期,4名患者在栓塞术后经历了过早绝经。有三个失败标准,患者只需符合其中一个:子宫切除术、UFE术后6个月肌瘤缩小<10%或UFE术后症状恶化。未发现年龄或子宫大小变量可预测失败。早期接受过盆腔手术的患者UFE失败的可能性更大(p = 0.012)。
子宫肌瘤栓塞术作为肌瘤的一种替代治疗方法,具有低发病率,可在社区医院环境中进行。88%的患者报告症状改善或稳定。栓塞术后6个月子宫总体积平均减少了49%。缩小不受UFE术前子宫大小、肌瘤大小或患者特征的影响。长期随访研究显示,12个月时子宫总体积和肌瘤持续显著缩小。肌瘤没有再生长。在我们的系列研究中,早期手术是预测UFE失败的一个因素。对未来生育的风险很小。