Jackson J L, Chamberlin J, Kroenke K
Department of Medicine, Uniformed Services University of the Health Sciences, Bethesda, MD 20814, USA.
Soc Sci Med. 2001 Feb;52(4):609-20. doi: 10.1016/s0277-9536(00)00164-7.
Correlates of patient satisfaction at varying points in time were assessed using a survey with 2-week and 3-month follow-up in a general medicine walk-in clinic, in USA. Five hundred adults presenting with a physical symptom, seen by one of 38 participating clinicians were surveyed and the following measurements were taken into account: patient symptom characteristics, symptom-related expectations, functional status (Medical Outcomes Study Short-Form Health Survey [SF-6]), mental disorders (PRIME-MD), symptom resolution, unmet expectations, satisfaction (RAND 9-item survey), visit costs and health utilization. Physician perception of difficulty (Difficult Doctor Patient Relationship Questionnaire), and Physician Belief Scale. Immediately after the visit, 260 (52%) patients were fully satisfied with their care, increasing to 59% at 2 weeks and 63% by 3 months. Patients older than 65 and those with better functional status were more likely to be satisfied. At all time points, the presence of unmet expectations markedly decreased satisfaction: immediately post-visit (OR: 0.14, 95% CI: 0.07-0.30), 2-week (OR: 0.07, 95% CI: 0.04-0.13) and 3-month (OR: 0.05, 95% CI: 0.03-0.09). Other independent variables predicting immediate after visit satisfaction included receiving an explanation of the likely cause as well as expected duration of the presenting symptom. At 2 weeks and 3 months, experiencing symptomatic improvement increased satisfaction while additional visits (actual or anticipated) for the same symptom decreased satisfaction. A lack of unmet expectations was a powerful predictor of satisfaction at all time-points. Immediately post-visit, other predictors of satisfaction reflected aspects of patient doctor communication (receiving an explanation of the symptom cause, likely duration, lack of unmet expectations), while 2-week and 3-month satisfaction reflected aspects of symptom outcome (symptom resolution, need for repeat visits, functional status). Patient satisfaction surveys need to carefully consider the sampling time frame as well as adjust for pertinent patient characteristics.
在美国一家普通内科即时诊疗诊所,通过一项包含2周和3个月随访的调查,评估了不同时间点患者满意度的相关因素。对38名参与诊疗的临床医生诊治的500名出现身体症状的成年人进行了调查,并考虑了以下测量指标:患者症状特征、与症状相关的期望、功能状态(医学结果研究简明健康调查[SF-6])、精神障碍(PRIME-MD)、症状缓解情况、未满足的期望、满意度(兰德9项调查)、就诊费用和医疗利用情况。医生对诊疗难度的感知(医患关系困难问卷)以及医生信念量表。就诊后即刻,260名(52%)患者对其诊疗完全满意,2周时这一比例增至59%,3个月时为63%。65岁以上的患者以及功能状态较好的患者更有可能感到满意。在所有时间点,未满足期望的存在均显著降低满意度:就诊后即刻(比值比:0.14,95%置信区间:0.07 - 0.30)、2周时(比值比:0.07,95%置信区间:0.04 - 0.13)和3个月时(比值比:0.05,95%置信区间:0.03 - 0.09)。预测就诊后即刻满意度的其他独立变量包括得到对当前症状可能病因及预期病程的解释。在2周和3个月时,症状改善会提高满意度,而针对相同症状的额外就诊(实际或预期的)会降低满意度。在所有时间点,未存在未满足的期望都是满意度的有力预测因素。就诊后即刻,其他满意度预测因素反映了医患沟通的方面(得到症状病因、可能病程的解释,不存在未满足的期望),而2周和3个月时的满意度反映了症状结果的方面(症状缓解、是否需要再次就诊、功能状态)。患者满意度调查需要仔细考虑抽样时间框架,并针对相关患者特征进行调整。