Palmer H E, Mukunyadzi P, Culbreth W, Thomas J R
Department of Pathology, University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences, Little Rock, Arkansas, USA.
Diagn Cytopathol. 2001 May;24(5):307-16. doi: 10.1002/dc.1067.
To evaluate the accuracy and reproducibility of subgrouping and grading soft-tissue sarcomas by fine-needle aspiration biopsy (FNAB), a blind review was conducted of 84 FNAB specimens from 77 malignant and 7 benign soft-tissue lesions. Cytomorphologic subgroups included 31 spindle-cell, 24 pleomorphic, 11 myxoid, 7 epithelioid/polygonal, 3 small round cell, and 8 nondiagnostic cases. Malignancies included one lymphoma and 41 primary, 15 recurrent, and 20 metastatic soft-tissue sarcomas. Adequacy was defined as a majority of slides with at least 5 clusters of 10 unobscured cells. Five originally false-negative cases were considered nondiagnostic on review. Sarcoma was recognized in 59 of 64 adequate cases (92%) with available histology; however, the specific histopathologic subtype was identified in only 9 cases (14%). Benign myxoid and spindle-cell lesions were difficult to separate from low-grade sarcomas in 4 cases, and a B-cell lymphoma with sclerosis mimicked a low-grade myxoid sarcoma. The assigned cytologic grade accurately reflected the histologic grade in 90% of sarcomas when segregated into high and low grades. Pleomorphic, small round cell, and epithelioid/polygonal subgroups corresponded to high-grade sarcomas in all cases with only minor noncorrelations. Major grading noncorrelations occurred in 50% of myxoid and 9% of spindle-cell sarcomas. Therefore, attention should be given to specimen adequacy, and caution should be exercised when attempting to grade myxoid and spindle-cell sarcomas by FNAB.
为评估细针穿刺活检(FNAB)对软组织肉瘤进行亚组划分和分级的准确性及可重复性,对来自77例恶性和7例良性软组织病变的84份FNAB标本进行了盲法评估。细胞形态学亚组包括31例梭形细胞、24例多形性、11例黏液样、7例上皮样/多边形、3例小圆形细胞以及8例无法诊断的病例。恶性肿瘤包括1例淋巴瘤以及41例原发性、15例复发性和20例转移性软组织肉瘤。标本充足定义为大多数载玻片上至少有5个由10个清晰细胞组成的细胞团。复查时,5例最初为假阴性的病例被判定为无法诊断。在64例有可用组织学检查结果的充足标本中,59例(92%)确诊为肉瘤;然而,仅9例(14%)明确了具体的组织病理学亚型。4例良性黏液样和梭形细胞病变难以与低级别肉瘤区分,1例伴有硬化的B细胞淋巴瘤酷似低级别黏液样肉瘤。当将肉瘤分为高级别和低级别时,90%的病例中指定的细胞学分级准确反映了组织学分级。多形性、小圆形细胞以及上皮样/多边形亚组在所有病例中均对应高级别肉瘤,仅有轻微不符。50%的黏液样肉瘤和9%的梭形细胞肉瘤出现主要分级不符。因此,应注意标本的充足性,在试图通过FNAB对黏液样和梭形细胞肉瘤进行分级时应谨慎。