Manil L, Voisin P, Aubert B, Guerreau D, Verrier P, Lebègue L, Wargnies J P, Di Paola M, Barbier Y, Chossat F, Menkes C J, Tébib J, Devaux J Y, Kahan A
CIS Bio International, F-91192 Gif-sur-Yvette, France.
Nucl Med Commun. 2001 Apr;22(4):405-16. doi: 10.1097/00006231-200104000-00009.
Physical and biological dosimetry were investigated in 45 rheumatoid arthritis patients treated by radiosynoviorthesis (RSO) with 186Re-sulphide (medium-sized joints) and 169Er-citrate (digital joints). Biological dosimetry involved scoring dicentrics in lymphocytes, cultured from blood samples withdrawn just before and 6 h, 24 h and 7 days after treatment. Physical methods included repeated blood sample counts and scintigraphy data. For erbium-169 (pure beta emitter), only bremsstrahlung could be measured and solely in the injection area. For rhenium-186 (both beta and gamma emitter), whole body scans and static images of joints and locoregional lymph nodes were performed. Dosimetry calculations were in accordance with the MIRDOSE 3 software and tables. For erbium-169 (21 patients), either metacarpophalangeal (30 MBq) or proximal interphalangeal (20 MBq) joints of the hands were treated (one joint per patient); 18 patients (out of 21) were interpretable for biological dosimetry, 10 (out of 11) for physical dosimetry and six (out of 10) for both. For rhenium-186, 23 wrists, nine elbows, three shoulders and two ankles were injected in 24 patients, with a maximum of three joints per patient (70 MBq per joint); 20 patients (out of 24) and 10 (out of 10) were interpretable for biological and physical dosimetry, respectively, and eight (out of 10) for both methods. Erbium-169 biological dosimetry was negative in all interpretable patients, and physical dosimetry gave a blood dose of 15 +/- 29 microGy and an effective dose lower than 1 mSv/30 MBq. For rhenium-186, biological results were negative in 16 patients (out of 20), but showed a blood irradiation around 200 mGy in the last four. A significant cumulative increase of dicentrics 7 days after injection (16/10,000 instead of 5/10,000 prior to treatment; p < 0.04) was also noted. Gamma counts gave a blood dose of 23.9 +/- 19.8 mGy/70 MBq and the effective dose was found to be 26.7 +/- 5.1 mGy/70 MBq, i.e. about 380 microGy.MBq-1. Erbium-169 RSO is very safe from both physical and biological dosimetry standpoints. Rhenium-186 leak is greater, as demonstrated by the higher blood activity and the measurable, although limited, dicentrics induction in blood lymphocytes. However, the effective dose remains moderate, i.e. 30 times lower than in 131I therapy in benign thyroid diseases.
对45例类风湿性关节炎患者进行了物理剂量测定和生物剂量测定,这些患者接受了放射性滑膜切除术(RSO),其中中型关节使用186Re-硫化物,手指关节使用169Er-柠檬酸盐。生物剂量测定包括对淋巴细胞中的双着丝粒进行评分,淋巴细胞取自治疗前及治疗后6小时、24小时和7天采集的血样。物理方法包括重复进行血样计数和闪烁扫描数据。对于铒-169(纯β发射体),仅能在注射区域测量轫致辐射。对于铼-186(β和γ发射体),进行了全身扫描以及关节和局部淋巴结的静态显像。剂量测定计算依据MIRDOSE 3软件和表格进行。对于铒-169(21例患者),治疗手部的掌指关节(30 MBq)或近端指间关节(20 MBq)(每位患者一个关节);21例患者中有18例可用于生物剂量测定,11例中有10例可用于物理剂量测定,10例中有6例两种剂量测定均可进行。对于铼-186,24例患者中注射了23个腕关节、9个肘关节、3个肩关节和2个踝关节,每位患者最多注射三个关节(每个关节70 MBq);24例患者中有20例可用于生物剂量测定,10例中有10例可用于物理剂量测定,两种方法均适用的有10例中的8例。铒-169生物剂量测定在所有可进行测定的患者中均为阴性,物理剂量测定得出的血液剂量为15±29 μGy,有效剂量低于1 mSv/30 MBq。对于铼-186,20例患者中有16例生物测定结果为阴性,但最后4例显示血液照射量约为200 mGy。还注意到注射后7天双着丝粒有显著的累积增加(16/10,000,而治疗前为5/10,000;p<0.04)。γ计数得出的血液剂量为23.9±19.8 mGy/70 MBq,有效剂量为26.7±5.1 mGy/70 MBq,即约380 μGy·MBq-1。从物理和生物剂量测定的角度来看,铒-169放射性滑膜切除术非常安全。铼-186的泄漏更大,这表现为血液活性更高以及血液淋巴细胞中可测量到(尽管有限)的双着丝粒诱导。然而,有效剂量仍然适中,即比良性甲状腺疾病的131I治疗低30倍。