Nelson M D, Parker B L, Al T A, Cherry J A, Loomer D
Department of Earth Sciences, University of Waterloo, Ontario, Canada.
Environ Sci Technol. 2001 Mar 15;35(6):1266-75. doi: 10.1021/es001207v.
Although the potential for KMnO4 to destroy chlorinated ethenes in situ was first recognized more than a decade ago, the geochemical processes that accompany the oxidation have not previously been examined. In this study, aqueous KMnO4 solutions (10-30 g/L) were injected into an unconfined sand aquifer contaminated by the dense non-aqueous-phase liquid (DNAPL) tetrachloroethylene (PCE). The effects of the injections were monitored using depth-specific, multilevel groundwater samplers, and continuous cores. Two distinct geochemical zones evolved within several days after injection. In one zone where DNAPL is present, reactions between KMnO4 and dissolved PCE resulted in the release of abundant chloride and hydrogen ions to the water. Calcite and dolomite dissolved, buffering the pH in the range of 5.8-6.5, releasing Ca, Mg, and CO2 to the pore water. In this zone, the aqueous Ca/Cl concentration ratio is close to 5:12, consistent with the following reaction for the oxidation of PCE in a carbonate-rich aquifer: 3C2Cl4 + 5CaCO3(s) + 4KMnO4 + 2H+ --> 11CO2 + 4MnO2(s) + H2O + 12Cl- + 5Ca2+ + 4K+. In addition to Mg from dolomite dissolution, increases in the concentration of Mg as well as Na may result from exchange with K at cation-exchange sites. In the second zone, where lesser amounts of PCE were present, KMnO4 persisted in the aquifer for more than 14 months, and the porewater pH increased graduallyto between 9 and 10 as a resultof reaction between KMnO4 and H2O. A small increase in SO4 concentrations in the zones invaded by KMnO4 suggests that KMnO4 injections caused oxidation of sulfide minerals. There are important benefits of carbonate mineral buffering during DNAPL remediation by in situ oxidation. In a carbonate-buffered system, Mn(VII) is reduced to Mn(IV) and is immobilized in the groundwater by precipitating as insoluble manganese oxide. Energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy analyses of the manganese oxide coatings on aquifer mineral grains have detected the impurities Al, Ca, Cl, Cu, Pb, P, K, Si, S, Ti, U, and Zn indicating that, similar to natural systems, precipitation of manganese oxide is accompanied by coprecipitation of other elements. In addition, the consumption of excess KMnO4 by reaction with reduced minerals such as magnetite will be minimized because the rates of these reactions increase with decreasing pH. Aquifer cores collected after the KMnO4 injections exhibit dark brown to black bands of manganese oxide reaction products in sand layers where DNAPL was originally present. Mineralogical investigations indicate that the manganese oxide coatings are uniformly distributed over the mineral grains. Observations of the coatings using transmission electron microscopy indicate that they are on the order of 1 microm thick, and consequently, the decrease in porosity through the formation of the coatings is negligible.
尽管十多年前人们就首次认识到高锰酸钾在原位破坏氯乙烯的潜力,但此前尚未对伴随氧化过程的地球化学过程进行研究。在本研究中,将高锰酸钾水溶液(10 - 30克/升)注入到受致密非水相液体(DNAPL)四氯乙烯(PCE)污染的无压砂质含水层中。使用深度特定的多级地下水采样器和连续岩芯监测注入的效果。注入后几天内形成了两个不同的地球化学带。在存在DNAPL的一个区域,高锰酸钾与溶解的PCE之间的反应导致大量氯离子和氢离子释放到水中。方解石和白云石溶解,将pH缓冲在5.8 - 6.5范围内,向孔隙水释放钙、镁和二氧化碳。在该区域,水相中的钙/氯浓度比接近5:12,这与富碳酸盐含水层中PCE氧化的以下反应一致:3C₂Cl₄ + 5CaCO₃(s) + 4KMnO₄ + 2H⁺ --> 11CO₂ + 4MnO₂(s) + H₂O + 12Cl⁻ + 5Ca²⁺ + 4K⁺。除了白云石溶解产生的镁之外,镁以及钠浓度的增加可能是由于在阳离子交换位点与钾发生交换所致。在第二个区域,PCE含量较少,高锰酸钾在含水层中持续存在超过14个月,并且由于高锰酸钾与水之间的反应,孔隙水pH逐渐升高至9到10之间。在高锰酸钾侵入的区域,硫酸根浓度有小幅增加,这表明注入高锰酸钾导致了硫化物矿物的氧化。在通过原位氧化修复DNAPL过程中,碳酸盐矿物缓冲具有重要益处。在碳酸盐缓冲系统中,锰(VII)被还原为锰(IV),并通过沉淀为不溶性锰氧化物而固定在地下水中。对含水层矿物颗粒上的锰氧化物涂层进行的能量色散X射线光谱分析检测到了杂质铝、钙、氯、铜、铅、磷、钾、硅、硫、钛、铀和锌,这表明与自然系统类似,锰氧化物的沉淀伴随着其他元素的共沉淀。此外,由于这些反应的速率随pH降低而增加,与磁铁矿等还原矿物反应消耗过量高锰酸钾的情况将降至最低。在注入高锰酸钾后采集的含水层岩芯在最初存在DNAPL的砂层中呈现出深棕色至黑色的锰氧化物反应产物带。矿物学研究表明,锰氧化物涂层均匀分布在矿物颗粒上。使用透射电子显微镜对涂层的观察表明,它们的厚度约为1微米,因此,通过形成涂层导致的孔隙度降低可以忽略不计。