Melzer S M, Molteni R A, Marcuse E K, Rivara F P
Department of Pediatrics, University of Washington School of Medicine and Children's Hospital and Regional Medical Center, Seattle, Washington, USA.
Pediatrics. 2001 Jul;108(1):79-84. doi: 10.1542/peds.108.1.79.
In many children's hospitals, inpatient attending physician services are provided by academic faculty who function as part-time inpatient specialists or hospitalists. Although some have claimed that hospitalist care can reduce length of stay and total hospital resource use and expenses, there are few benchmarks or data regarding physician productivity or the characteristics and financial performance of these programs. The resource-based relative value scale (RBRVS) is a valuable tool for developing national benchmarks and comparing the financial performance of inpatient programs at varying daily census and reimbursement levels. The objectives of this study were to 1) describe physician productivity on an inpatient service as measured by total relative value units (TRVUs) and professional charges, 2) determine whether inpatient collections were adequate to support faculty salaries for the time spent attending, and 3) develop a model to evaluate financial performance of inpatient programs at varying census and TRVU reimbursement levels.
A retrospective review of hospital discharge and faculty practice billing data between June 1997 and July 1998 was conducted in a general medical service in a regional, 208-bed, university-affiliated children's hospital in the Pacific Northwest.
Of 4113 patients who were admitted to the children's hospital general medical service during a 12-month period, faculty part-time hospitalists (N = 28) served as the attending physician for 1738 (42%). On an annual basis, faculty attended for an average of 29.1 days (median: 21.0; range: 7.0-97.0), with an average daily patient census (ADC) of 7.2 (median: 6.5; range: 2.8-12.0). Inpatient attendings billed for 1738 initial visits and 3957 subsequent visits. Total physician productivity for the inpatient attending group during 1 year included 12 085 TRVUs and gross professional charges of $777 743. The average payment, or conversion factor (CF), was $24.46/TRVU (71% of Medicare CF). The cash collection rate was 38%, reflecting a payor mix that included 54% Medicaid, 28% commercial payors, 12% health maintenance organization, and 6% other payors. On a weekly basis, physicians generated an average of 109 TRVUs and collected $2665 in cash. The average salary cost per RVU was $23.40, and weekly faculty salary and benefit expenses were $2550. After operating expenses and academic taxes totaling 24% were deducted ($5.87/TRVU), RBRVS-based payments and cash collections covered 79% of average faculty weekly salaries. Financial modeling showed that either an average CF of $31/TRVU or an ADC of 9 patients per day on the inpatient service would be required to generate sufficient revenue to support physician salaries and operating expenses.
For a faculty inpatient attending service in a children's hospital with an ADC of 7, a $24.46 RBRVS-based CF payment is inadequate to support faculty salaries and operating expenses for the time spent attending. Inpatient services in similar payor environments with comparable expenses and staffed by faculty who care for fewer than 9 patients per day will not cover typical faculty salary costs and operating expenses.
在许多儿童医院,住院主治医师服务由担任兼职住院专科医生或住院医师的学术教员提供。尽管有人声称住院医师护理可缩短住院时间、减少医院资源总使用量和费用,但关于医师工作效率或这些项目的特征及财务表现,几乎没有基准或数据。基于资源的相对价值尺度(RBRVS)是制定全国基准以及比较不同日普查量和报销水平下住院项目财务表现的宝贵工具。本研究的目的是:1)以总相对价值单位(TRVUs)和专业收费衡量住院服务中医师的工作效率;2)确定住院收入是否足以支付教员出诊时间的薪水;3)建立一个模型来评估不同普查量和TRVU报销水平下住院项目的财务表现。
对太平洋西北部一家拥有208张床位的地区性大学附属医院普通内科1997年6月至1998年7月期间的医院出院数据和教员执业计费数据进行回顾性分析。
在12个月期间入住儿童医院普通内科的4113例患者中,教员兼职住院医师(N = 28)担任主治医师的有1738例(42%)。每年,教员平均出诊29.1天(中位数:21.0;范围:7.0 - 97.0),日均患者普查量(ADC)为7.2(中位数:6.5;范围:2.8 - 12.0)。住院主治医师开出了1738次初诊和3957次复诊账单。住院主治医师组1年的总医师工作效率包括12085个TRVUs,专业总收费为777743美元。平均支付或换算因子(CF)为每TRVU 24.46美元(医疗保险CF的71%)。现金收款率为38%,反映出付款方构成包括54%的医疗补助、28%的商业付款方、12%的健康维护组织和6%的其他付款方。每周,医师平均产生109个TRVUs,现金收款2665美元。每个RVU的平均薪资成本为23.40美元,教员每周的薪资和福利费用为2550美元。扣除总计24%的运营费用和学术税(每TRVU 5.87美元)后,基于RBRVS的付款和现金收款覆盖了教员平均周薪的79%。财务模型显示,住院服务要么平均CF为每TRVU 31美元,要么日均患者普查量为9例,才能产生足够收入来支持医师薪资和运营费用。
对于一家日均患者普查量为7的儿童医院的教员住院主治医师服务,基于RBRVS的每TRVU 24.46美元的CF支付不足以支付教员出诊时间的薪水和运营费用。在类似付款方环境、费用相当且每天照顾患者少于9例的教员配备的住院服务中,无法覆盖典型的教员薪资成本和运营费用。