Tondo L, Baldessarini R J, Floris G
Department of Psychology, University of Cagliari, Sardinia, Italy and McLean Hospital, Department of Psychiatry, Harvard Medical School, Boston, USA.
Br J Psychiatry Suppl. 2001 Jun;41:s184-90.
The effectiveness of lithium is being questioned increasingly and requires clarification.
To assess the effectiveness of lithium treatment in depression and mania, syndromal types I and II, with predominantly mixed or psychotic episodes or rapid cycling, during treatment resumed following discontinuation, and across three decades.
The longitudinal course of 360 patients with bipolar disorder compliant with lithium treatment for at least 1 year and without comorbidity for substance use disorder was reviewed.
Risk of single-episode recurrences, a common index of treatment failure, was similar to that in other reports. Both episode frequency and 'time ill' improved more in type II than type I cases. Reduced morbidity during treatment was similar in patients with mixed or psychotic episodes, or rapid cycling, and in less complex cases. Retreatment yielded minor decrements in response, and there was no tendency for lesser responses in more recent years.
Based on overall affective morbidity, long-term lithium treatment in compliant patients without comorbid substance use disorder, though imperfect, remains effective, even in subgroups of supposedly poor prognosis.
锂盐的有效性日益受到质疑,需要予以澄清。
评估锂盐治疗在抑郁和躁狂(I型和II型综合征,主要为混合性或精神病性发作或快速循环发作)中的有效性,评估在停药后恢复治疗期间以及三十年中的有效性。
回顾了360例双相情感障碍患者的纵向病程,这些患者接受锂盐治疗至少1年且无物质使用障碍合并症。
单次发作复发风险是治疗失败的常见指标,与其他报告相似。II型病例的发作频率和“患病时间”改善均优于I型病例。混合性或精神病性发作、快速循环发作患者与病情不太复杂的患者在治疗期间发病率降低情况相似。再次治疗时反应略有下降,近年来没有反应较小的趋势。
基于总体情感发病率,对于无物质使用障碍合并症的依从性患者,长期锂盐治疗虽不完美,但仍然有效,即使在预后可能较差的亚组中也是如此。