Shah N N, Bayliss N C, Malcolm A
Orthopaedics Department, King's College Hospital, Denmark Hill, London, United Kingdom.
J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 2001 Jul-Aug;10(4):309-16. doi: 10.1067/mse.2001.114681.
Debate continues as to whether the differing shapes of the acromion are congenital or acquired. This has been investigated by neonatal cadaver study, adult cadaver study, radiographic study, magnetic resonance imaging study, or various other means. No one, to our knowledge, has investigated this by histologic study. A macroscopic and histologic study of 22 cadaveric shoulder joints was carried out to establish what, if any, developmental changes occur in the differing patterns of acromion. The cadaveric shoulders were dissected and examined macroscopically. All of the acromion processes were transected and photographed, and the histology of the anterior and inferior surfaces was studied. In all of the curved and hooked types of acromion, a common pattern of degeneration of collagen, fibrocartilage, and bone was observed, consistent with a traction phenomenon. None of the flat acromions exhibited these changes. Extensive histologic changes were noted on the anterior surface of acromion as compared to the inferior surface in curved or hooked acromion. We conclude that the different shapes of acromion are, therefore, acquired as a response to traction forces applied via the coracoacromial ligament and are not congenital in origin.
关于肩峰不同形状是先天性还是后天性的争论仍在继续。这已通过新生儿尸体研究、成人尸体研究、放射学研究、磁共振成像研究或其他各种方法进行了调查。据我们所知,没有人通过组织学研究对此进行过调查。对22个尸体肩关节进行了宏观和组织学研究,以确定肩峰不同形态中是否发生了发育变化(如果有的话)。对尸体肩部进行解剖并进行宏观检查。所有肩峰都被横切并拍照,并研究其前表面和下表面的组织学。在所有弯曲型和钩型肩峰中,均观察到胶原蛋白、纤维软骨和骨的常见退变模式,这与牵引现象一致。所有扁平肩峰均未出现这些变化。与弯曲或钩型肩峰的下表面相比,其前表面有广泛的组织学变化。因此,我们得出结论,肩峰的不同形状是后天获得的,是对通过喙肩韧带施加的牵引力的反应,而非先天性起源。