Koelmans A A, Van Der Heijde A, Knijff L M, Aalderin R H
Aquatic Ecology and Water Quality Management Group, Department of Environmental Sciences, Wageningen University, Netherlands.
Water Res. 2001 Oct;35(15):3517-36. doi: 10.1016/s0043-1354(01)00095-1.
Eutrophication and contamination with micropollutants have been major problems in water quality management. Both problems have been subjected to extensive research and modelling but traditionally are treated separately. Traditional simulation models for aquatic systems can be categorised as eutrophication models, contaminant fate models, food web models and food chain bioaccumulation models. Because they are single issue models, many interactions and feedbacks between the food web, nutrient and toxicant cycles are missed. Linking these models is essential to evaluate the fate and risks of contaminants in systems with changing nutrient loading, to assess the natural attenuation of contaminants or to understand the selfpurifying capacity of ecosystems. Combination of the single issue models requires inclusion of 'interaction processes' to account for the coupling between the (sub-) model types, such as organic carbon cycling. toxicity, transport and accumulation of organic contaminants in the food chain, and bottom up versus top down control of primary production and nutrient cycling. This review first provides a brief overview of traditional approaches in modelling eutrophication, contaminant fate, food web dynamics and food chain bioaccumulation. Second, five existing integrated eutrophication, fate and/or effects models are reviewed. Third, the gaps and limitations in modelling the four types of interaction processes are discussed. It is concluded that these models are invaluable tools to focus attention to feedback mechanisms that are often overlooked, to identify dominating processes in ecosystems, to formulate counterintuitive hypotheses on ecosystem functioning, or to assess short term risks of acutely toxic stressors. However, the potential of integrated models for long term simulations of contaminant exposure. food chain bioaccumulation and effects to higher trophic levels remains limited, mainly because of principal limitations in food web modelling. In contrast, the potential of integrated models for long term simulations of contaminant fate is better because the environmental distribution of contaminants is mainly determined by the major abiotic compartments and by biotic compartments at the base of the food chain.
富营养化和微污染物污染一直是水质管理中的主要问题。这两个问题都已得到广泛研究和建模,但传统上是分开处理的。水生系统的传统模拟模型可分为富营养化模型、污染物归宿模型、食物网模型和食物链生物累积模型。由于它们是单一问题模型,因此遗漏了食物网、营养物质和毒物循环之间的许多相互作用和反馈。将这些模型联系起来对于评估营养负荷变化的系统中污染物的归宿和风险、评估污染物的自然衰减或了解生态系统的自净能力至关重要。单一问题模型的组合需要纳入“相互作用过程”,以考虑(子)模型类型之间的耦合,如有机碳循环、有机污染物在食物链中的毒性、运输和累积,以及初级生产和营养物质循环的自下而上与自上而下控制。本综述首先简要概述了富营养化、污染物归宿、食物网动态和食物链生物累积建模的传统方法。其次,对五个现有的富营养化、归宿和/或效应综合模型进行了综述。第三,讨论了四种相互作用过程建模中的差距和局限性。得出的结论是,这些模型是非常有价值的工具,可用于关注那些经常被忽视的反馈机制、识别生态系统中的主导过程、提出关于生态系统功能的反直觉假设,或评估急性毒性应激源的短期风险。然而,综合模型在长期模拟污染物暴露、食物链生物累积以及对较高营养级的影响方面的潜力仍然有限,主要是因为食物网建模存在主要局限性。相比之下,综合模型在长期模拟污染物归宿方面的潜力更好,因为污染物的环境分布主要由主要的非生物区室和食物链底部的生物区室决定。