Fujita A, Nakamura M, Tamaki N
Department of Neurosurgery, Kobe University School of Medicine, 7-5-1 Kusunoki-cho, Chuo-ku, Kobe-city, Hyogo 650-0017, Japan.
No Shinkei Geka. 2001 Nov;29(11):1065-72.
Multiple dural arteriovenous fistulas (DAVFs) are rare, accounting for 7% of all intracranial DAVFs. The authors describe two cases of multiple DAVFs involving both the cavernous sinus and the posterior fossa. The first patient was a 45-year-old man who presented with visual disturbance, chemosis, exophthalmus, and tinnitus. Angiograms demonstrated DAVFs involving the right cavernous sinus and the ipsilateral sigmoid sinus. Soon after transarterial embolization via the right occipital artery, the patient's symptoms completely disappeared. Six months later, follow-up angiograms showed disappearance of the cavernous DAVF and a subtle opacification of the sigmoid sinus DAVF. The patient has been free from symptoms for four years. The second patient was a 75-year-old woman who presented with progressive tinnitus two years after stereotactic radiosurgery for right cavernous DAVF. Angiograms showed a new lesion in the contralateral transverse and sigmoid sinuses. Transvenous embolization (TVE) of the affected sinuses was successful and the patient's symptoms disappeared. The patient's course has been uneventful after treatment, and follow-up MR angiograms have not shown any recurrence of lesions. To our knowledge, 25 cases of multiple DAVFs have been reported in the literature, of which we reviewed 12 cases of multiple DAVFs affecting the cavernous sinus. The patients' ages ranged from 43 to 75 years with a mean of 57.4 and their distribution showed female predominance. Other DAVFs occurred mostly in the transverse and sigmoid sinuses. With the exception of our case (second patient), the posterior fossa lesions were located on the same side as the cavernous sinus DAVF. Multiple DAVFs were detected simultaneously in 5 of the 12 cases with the initial angiograms. In the other 7 cases, cavernous DAVFs had been treated, but were followed by posterior fossa lesions occurring after various intervals (4 months to 2.5 years). All the patients presented with ocular signs due to cavernous DAVFs. Based upon our review of the literature, we discuss here three possible hypotheses. The first possibility for formation of multiple DAVFs concerns their primary etiology, viz. that they develop after a huge sinus thrombosis involving several sinuses and its recanalization. A second possibility is the secondary formation of DAVFs. Preexisting cavernous sinus DAVFs induce sinus thrombosis and/or venous hypertension, which results in the formation of multiple lesions. A third possibility is that they are due to other factors, including increased angiogenic activity and some technical problems associated with TVE. Our review indicates that careful follow-up for several years should be made after treatment of cavernous DAVFs.
多发性硬脑膜动静脉瘘(DAVF)较为罕见,占所有颅内DAVF的7%。作者描述了两例累及海绵窦和后颅窝的多发性DAVF病例。首例患者为一名45岁男性,表现为视力障碍、结膜水肿、眼球突出和耳鸣。血管造影显示DAVF累及右侧海绵窦和同侧乙状窦。经右侧枕动脉进行经动脉栓塞后不久,患者症状完全消失。6个月后,随访血管造影显示海绵窦DAVF消失,乙状窦DAVF有轻微显影。该患者已无症状4年。第二例患者为一名75岁女性,在对右侧海绵窦DAVF进行立体定向放射治疗两年后出现进行性耳鸣。血管造影显示对侧横窦和乙状窦有新病变。对受累窦进行经静脉栓塞(TVE)成功,患者症状消失。治疗后患者病情平稳,随访磁共振血管造影未显示病变复发。据我们所知,文献中已报道25例多发性DAVF,其中我们回顾了12例累及海绵窦的多发性DAVF。患者年龄在43至75岁之间,平均年龄为57.4岁,且分布显示女性占优势。其他DAVF大多发生在横窦和乙状窦。除我们的病例(第二例患者)外,后颅窝病变与海绵窦DAVF位于同一侧。12例患者中有5例在初次血管造影时同时检测到多发性DAVF。在其他7例中,海绵窦DAVF已接受治疗,但随后在不同间隔时间(4个月至2.5年)出现后颅窝病变。所有患者均因海绵窦DAVF出现眼部体征。基于我们对文献的回顾,我们在此讨论三种可能的假说。多发性DAVF形成的第一种可能性涉及其原发性病因,即它们在涉及多个窦的巨大窦血栓形成及其再通后发展而来。第二种可能性是DAVF继发性形成。先前存在的海绵窦DAVF诱发窦血栓形成和/或静脉高压,从而导致多个病变形成。第三种可能性是它们归因于其他因素,包括血管生成活性增加以及与TVE相关的一些技术问题。我们的回顾表明,在治疗海绵窦DAVF后应进行数年的仔细随访。