Warheit D B, Hart G A, Hesterberg T W, Collins J J, Dyer W M, Swaen G M, Castranova V, Soiefer A I, Kennedy G L
DuPont Haskell Lab.
Crit Rev Toxicol. 2001 Nov;31(6):697-736. doi: 10.1080/20014091111965.
In the first half of the twentieth century epidemiologic evidence linked elevated incidences of pulmonary fibrosis and cancer with inhalation of chrysotile and crocidolite asbestos, a family of naturally occurring inorganic fibrous materials. As the serpentine and amphibole forms of asbestos were phased out, synthetic vitreous fibers (SVFs; fiber glass, mineral wool, and refractory fiber) became increasingly utilized, and concerns were raised that they too might cause adverse health effects. Extensive toxicological research on SVFs has demonstrated that their pulmonary effects are directly related to fiber dose in the lung over time. This is the result of deposition (thin fibers deposit in the lower lung more efficiently than thick fibers) and lung-persistence ("biopersistence" is directly related to fiber length and inversely related to dissolution and fragmentation rates). In rat inhalation studies, asbestos was determined to be 7- to 10-fold more biopersistent in the lung than SVFs. Other than its effect on biopersistence, fiber composition did not appear to play a direct role in the biological activity of SVFs. Recently, the utilization of man-made organic fibers (MMOFs) (also referred to by some as synthetic organic fibers) has increased rapidly for a variety of applications. In contrast to SVFs, research on the potential pulmonary effects of MMOFs is relatively limited, because traditionally MMOFs were manufactured in diameters too thick to be respirable (inhalable into the lower lung). However, new developments in the MMOF industry have resulted in the production of increasingly fine-diameter fibers for special applications, and certain post-manufacturing processes (e.g., chopping) generate respirable-sized MMOF dust. Until the mid-1990s, there was no consistent evidence of human health affects attributed to occupational exposure to MMOFs. Very recently, however, a unique form of interstitial lung disease has been reported in nylon flock workers in three different plants, and respirable-sized nylon shreds (including fibers) were identified in workplace air samples. Whether nylon dust or other occupational exposures are responsible for the development of lung disease in these workers remains to be determined. It is also unknown whether the biological mechanisms that determine the respirability and toxicity of SVFs apply to MMOFs. Thus, it is appropriate and timely to review the current data regarding MMOF workplace exposure and pulmonary health effects, including the database on epidemiological, exposure assessment, and toxicology studies.
在20世纪上半叶,流行病学证据表明,吸入温石棉和青石棉(一类天然存在的无机纤维材料)会使肺纤维化和癌症的发病率升高。随着蛇纹石和闪石形式的石棉逐渐被淘汰,合成玻璃纤维(SVFs;玻璃纤维、矿棉和耐火纤维)的使用越来越广泛,人们担心它们也可能对健康产生不利影响。对合成玻璃纤维进行的广泛毒理学研究表明,它们对肺部的影响与肺部纤维剂量随时间的变化直接相关。这是沉积(细纤维比粗纤维更有效地沉积在肺下部)和肺部持久性(“生物持久性”与纤维长度直接相关,与溶解和破碎率成反比)的结果。在大鼠吸入研究中,确定石棉在肺部的生物持久性比合成玻璃纤维高7至10倍。除了对生物持久性的影响外,纤维成分似乎在合成玻璃纤维的生物活性中不发挥直接作用。最近,人造有机纤维(MMOFs)(也被一些人称为合成有机纤维)在各种应用中的使用迅速增加。与合成玻璃纤维相比,对人造有机纤维潜在肺部影响的研究相对有限,因为传统上人造有机纤维的制造直径太厚,无法被吸入(吸入到肺下部)。然而,人造有机纤维行业的新发展导致生产出越来越细直径的纤维用于特殊应用,并且某些制造后工艺(例如切碎)会产生可吸入尺寸的人造有机纤维粉尘。直到20世纪90年代中期,没有一致的证据表明职业接触人造有机纤维会对人类健康产生影响。然而,最近,在三家不同工厂的尼龙绒毛工人中报告了一种独特形式的间质性肺病,并且在工作场所空气样本中发现了可吸入尺寸的尼龙碎片(包括纤维)。这些工人肺部疾病的发展是由尼龙粉尘还是其他职业暴露引起的仍有待确定。决定合成玻璃纤维可吸入性和毒性的生物学机制是否适用于人造有机纤维也不清楚。因此,审查当前关于人造有机纤维工作场所暴露和肺部健康影响的数据,包括流行病学、暴露评估和毒理学研究数据库,是恰当且及时的。