Soustiel Jean F, Shik Venyamin, Shreiber Reuven, Tavor Yonit, Goldsher Dorith
Department of Neurosurgery, Rambam Medical Center, Bruce Rappaport Faculty of Medicine, The Technion, Israel Institute of Technology, Haifa, Israel.
Stroke. 2002 Jan;33(1):72-7. doi: 10.1161/hs0102.100484.
Numerous studies have shown that cerebral vasospasm is one of the leading causes of death and neurological disability after subarachnoid hemorrhage. Most of these studies, however, have focused on anterior circulation vessels. Since the introduction of the transcranial Doppler (TCD), increasing attention has been given to basilar artery (BA) vasospasm, especially in traumatic subarachnoid hemorrhage. As shown for the anterior circulation, however, the significance of elevated flow velocities (FVs) in the posterior vessels may be ambiguous, so vasospasm may not be reliably differentiated from hyperemia. The purpose of the present study was to evaluate the potential additional value of an intracranial/extracranial FV ratio in the posterior circulation to cope with this shortcoming of the TCD in the diagnosis of BA vasospasm.
FV in the extracranial vertebral artery (VA) was measured in 20 healthy volunteers. Normative values of an intracranial/extracranial VA FV ratio (IVA/EVA) and a BA/extracranial VA FV ratio (BA/EVA) were calculated. Thirty-four patients with subarachnoid hemorrhage were then evaluated with TCD and CT angiography (CTA). The value of the IVA/EVA and BA/EVA ratios in the diagnosis and assessment of vertebrobasilar vasospasm was investigated.
The extracranial VA could be insonated in all subjects at depths ranging from 45 to 55 mm. The average FV for the extracranial VA was 26 cm/s. The ratios between intracranial and extracranial VA FVs were 1.6 on both sides, whereas the ratio between the BA FVs and the mean extracranial VA FVs was slightly higher at 1.7. Fourteen patients (41.2%) had CTA evidence of BA vasospasm. Vasospasm was severe in 7 patients, moderate in 1, and mild in the remaining. An FV threshold of 80 cm/s was indicative of BA vasospasm in 92.8% with 3 false-positive results that could be related to vertebrobasilar hyperemia. Comparative analysis between CTA and TCD findings showed that BA/EVA was >2 in all patients with BA vasospasm (100% sensitivity) and < 2 in all but 1 patient without BA vasospasm (95% specificity). Furthermore, the BA/EVA ratio showed a close correlation with BA diameter (r=-0.8139, P<0.0001) and was >3 in all patients with severe vasospasm.
The results of the present study showed that the BA/EVA ratio may contribute to an improved discrimination between BA vasospasm and vertebrobasilar hyperemia and enhance the accuracy and reliability of TCD in the diagnosis of BA vasospasm. Our data further suggest that the BA/EVA ratio may provide an approximation of vasospasm severity and help in identifying patients who are likely to suffer from hemodynamically significant vasospasm.
大量研究表明,脑血管痉挛是蛛网膜下腔出血后死亡和神经功能残疾的主要原因之一。然而,这些研究大多集中在前循环血管。自从经颅多普勒(TCD)问世以来,基底动脉(BA)痉挛越来越受到关注,尤其是在创伤性蛛网膜下腔出血中。然而,正如在前循环中所显示的那样,后循环血管中血流速度(FV)升高的意义可能并不明确,因此血管痉挛可能无法与充血可靠地区分开来。本研究的目的是评估颅内/颅外FV比值在后循环中的潜在附加价值,以应对TCD在诊断BA痉挛方面的这一缺点。
测量了20名健康志愿者颅外椎动脉(VA)的FV。计算了颅内/颅外VA FV比值(IVA/EVA)和BA/颅外VA FV比值(BA/EVA)的正常数值。然后对34例蛛网膜下腔出血患者进行了TCD和CT血管造影(CTA)评估。研究了IVA/EVA和BA/EVA比值在诊断和评估椎基底动脉痉挛中的价值。
在所有受试者中,颅外VA均可在45至55毫米的深度进行探测。颅外VA的平均FV为26厘米/秒。两侧颅内和颅外VA FV的比值均为1.6,而BA FV与颅外VA平均FV的比值略高,为1.7。14例患者(41.2%)有CTA证据显示BA痉挛。7例患者痉挛严重,1例中度,其余为轻度。FV阈值为80厘米/秒时,92.8%的患者可诊断为BA痉挛,有3例假阳性结果可能与椎基底动脉充血有关。CTA和TCD结果的对比分析显示,所有BA痉挛患者的BA/EVA均>2(敏感性100%),除1例无BA痉挛患者外,所有患者的BA/EVA均<2(特异性95%)。此外,BA/EVA比值与BA直径密切相关(r=-0.8139,P<0.0001),所有严重痉挛患者的BA/EVA均>3。
本研究结果表明,BA/EVA比值可能有助于更好地区分BA痉挛和椎基底动脉充血,并提高TCD诊断BA痉挛的准确性和可靠性。我们的数据进一步表明,BA/EVA比值可能提供痉挛严重程度的近似值,并有助于识别可能患有血流动力学显著痉挛的患者。