Park G B, Moon S S, Ko Y D, Ha J K, Lee J G, Chang H H, Joo S T
Division of Animal Science, Gyeongsang National University, Chinju, Korea.
J Anim Sci. 2002 Jan;80(1):129-36. doi: 10.2527/2002.801129x.
To assess the effects of slaughter weight and sex on APGS (Animal Products Grading Service) quality and APGS yield grade of Korean Hanwoo (n = 20,881) cattle, data were collected from cow, bull, and steer carcasses during a 1-yr period. Factors used to determine quality grade (marbling, meat color, fat color, texture, and overall maturity score) and yield grade (cold carcass weight, adjusted fat thickness, and longissimus muscle area) by the Korean grading system were recorded. Both yield and quality grades were improved (P < 0.01) with heavier slaughter weight, but there was no difference in yield grade for Hanwoo cattle classes heavier than 551 kg (P > 0.01). Longissimus muscle area, adjusted fat thickness, and marbling score increased (P < 0.01) with carcass weight. Bull carcasses showed higher yield but lower quality than those of cows or steers (P < 0.01). The quality grade of steer carcasses was higher (P < 0.01) than that of cow carcasses due to higher marbling scores, lower maturity scores, and heavier carcass weights. Hanwoo carcasses with larger longissimus muscle areas in relation to their carcass weight had lower APGS quality grades. The APGS quality grades were different between yield grade A and B carcasses (P < 0.01), but quality grade was not improved by increased fat thickness beyond the point of yield grade B. Adjusted fat thickness and marbling score showed significant (P < 0.01) differences among all yield grade classes, and this resulted in increased quality grade as yield grade decreased. Adjusted fat thickness showed the strongest correlation (r = -0.63) with yield grade, whereas marbling score had the strongest correlation (r = 0.81) with quality grade. Results showed a negative effect of castration on yield but a positive effect on quality. Also, data showed that Hanwoo carcasses with heavier weights had higher quality grades than those of lighter weight.
为评估屠宰体重和性别对韩国韩牛(n = 20,881)的畜产品分级服务(APGS)质量和APGS产量等级的影响,在1年时间里收集了母牛、公牛和阉牛胴体的数据。记录了韩国分级系统用于确定质量等级(大理石花纹、肉色、脂肪颜色、质地和总体成熟度评分)和产量等级(冷胴体重、调整后的脂肪厚度和背最长肌面积)的因素。随着屠宰体重增加,产量和质量等级均得到改善(P < 0.01),但体重超过551 kg的韩牛类别在产量等级上没有差异(P > 0.01)。背最长肌面积、调整后的脂肪厚度和大理石花纹评分随胴体重量增加而增加(P < 0.01)。公牛胴体的产量高于母牛或阉牛,但质量低于母牛或阉牛(P < 0.01)。阉牛胴体的质量等级高于母牛胴体(P < 0.01),这是由于大理石花纹评分更高、成熟度评分更低且胴体重量更重。相对于胴体重量,背最长肌面积较大的韩牛胴体的APGS质量等级较低。APGS质量等级在产量等级A和B的胴体之间存在差异(P < 0.01),但脂肪厚度超过产量等级B的点后,质量等级并未因脂肪厚度增加而提高。调整后的脂肪厚度和大理石花纹评分在所有产量等级类别之间存在显著差异(P < 0.01),这导致随着产量等级降低质量等级提高。调整后的脂肪厚度与产量等级的相关性最强(r = -0.63),而大理石花纹评分与质量等级的相关性最强(r = 0.81)。结果表明去势对产量有负面影响,但对质量有正面影响。此外,数据显示体重较重的韩牛胴体的质量等级高于体重较轻的胴体。