Andoh Benjamin
Law School, Southampton Institute.
Med Sci Law. 2002 Jan;42(1):14-26. doi: 10.1177/002580240204200104.
Although there are several works on mental hospitals, the legal aspects of mental hospital regime have not been comprehensively studied. This paper aims to fill that gap as regards England and Wales. The empirical study was conducted in a conventional English mental hospital which was within the National Health Service. After the introduction and a brief account of modes of admission to mental hospitals, the paper focuses on various aspects of mental hospital regime such as hospital rules and policies, daily routine, treatment without consent, seclusion, close observation, searches of patients and their property, restrictions on mail, etc., and then discusses the question of their legality, characterised by the tussle between the rights of patients and the rights of society. The paper concludes that although the regimes in mental hospitals may be considered reasonable and necessary, certain features of them (e.g., treatment without consent and searches of patients and their property) are controversial.
尽管有几部关于精神病院的著作,但精神病院管理制度的法律层面尚未得到全面研究。本文旨在填补英格兰和威尔士在这方面的空白。实证研究是在一家隶属于国民医疗服务体系的传统英国精神病院进行的。在引言部分及简要介绍精神病院的收治模式之后,本文重点关注精神病院管理制度的各个方面,如医院规则与政策、日常安排、未经同意的治疗、隔离、密切观察、对患者及其财物的搜查、对邮件的限制等,然后讨论这些方面的合法性问题,其特点是患者权利与社会权利之间的较量。本文的结论是,尽管精神病院的管理制度可能被认为合理且必要,但其某些特征(例如未经同意的治疗以及对患者及其财物的搜查)存在争议。