Goldberg S Nahum, Kamel Ihab R, Kruskal Jonathan B, Reynolds Kevin, Monsky Wayne L, Stuart Keith E, Ahmed Muneeb, Raptopoulos Vassilos
Department of Radiology, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, Harvard Medical School, 330 Brookline Ave, Boston, MA 02215, USA.
AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2002 Jul;179(1):93-101. doi: 10.2214/ajr.179.1.1790093.
The purpose of this study was to determine whether the administration of liposomal doxorubicin before radiofrequency ablation increases coagulation more than radiofrequency alone in focal hepatic tumors.
Fourteen focal hepatic tumors (diameter: mean +/- SD, 4.0+/-1.8 cm) in 10 patients (colorectal cancer, n = 3 patients; hepatocellular carcinoma, n = 4; neuroendocrine tumor, n = 2; breast cancer, n = 1) were treated with internally cooled radiofrequency ablation. In addition to undergoing radiofrequency, five patients (n = 7 lesions) were randomly assigned to receive 20 mg of IV doxorubicin in a long-circulating stealth liposome carrier (Doxil) 24 hr before ablation. Contrast-enhanced helical CT was performed immediately (within 30 min) after radiofrequency ablation (baseline) and 2-4 weeks after ablation. The volume of induced coagulation was measured by three-dimensional reconstruction techniques, and the measurements were compared.
For tumors treated with radiofrequency alone, the volume of the thermal lesion had decreased 12-24% (mean +/- SD, 82.5% +/- 4.4% of initial volume) at 2-4 weeks after ablation. By comparison, increased tumor destruction at 2-4 weeks after ablation was observed for all lesions treated with combined Doxil and radiofrequency (p<0.001). Six lesions increased 24-36% in volume, and coagulation surrounding a small colorectal metastasis increased 342%. No coagulation was identified in four unablated control lesions in the two patients receiving Doxil alone.
Our pilot clinical study suggests that adjuvant Doxil chemotherapy increases tumor destruction compared with radiofrequency ablation therapy alone in a variety of focal hepatic tumors. Optimization of this synergistic strategy may ultimately allow improved clinical efficacy and outcome.
本研究旨在确定在局灶性肝肿瘤中,射频消融术前给予脂质体阿霉素是否比单纯射频消融更能增强凝固作用。
10例患者(结肠癌3例;肝细胞癌4例;神经内分泌肿瘤2例;乳腺癌1例)的14个局灶性肝肿瘤(直径:平均±标准差,4.0±1.8 cm)接受了水冷式射频消融治疗。除接受射频消融外,5例患者(7个病灶)被随机分配在消融前24小时静脉注射20 mg阿霉素长循环隐形脂质体载体(多美素)。射频消融术后立即(30分钟内)及术后2 - 4周进行对比增强螺旋CT检查。采用三维重建技术测量诱导凝固体积,并对测量结果进行比较。
对于单纯接受射频消融治疗的肿瘤,消融后2 - 4周热损伤体积减少了12 - 24%(平均±标准差,为初始体积的82.5%±4.4%)。相比之下,所有接受多美素联合射频消融治疗的病灶在消融后2 - 4周均观察到肿瘤破坏增加(p<0.001)。6个病灶体积增加了24 - 36%,一个小的结直肠癌转移灶周围的凝固增加了342%。在仅接受多美素治疗的2例患者的4个未消融对照病灶中未发现凝固现象。
我们的初步临床研究表明,在多种局灶性肝肿瘤中,与单纯射频消融治疗相比,辅助多美素化疗可增加肿瘤破坏。优化这种协同策略最终可能提高临床疗效和预后。