Rosenheck Robert A, Lam Julie, Morrissey Joseph P, Calloway Michael O, Stolar Marilyn, Randolph Frances
Northeast Program Evaluation Center, Department of Veterans Affairs, West Haven, CT 06516, USA.
Psychiatr Serv. 2002 Aug;53(8):958-66. doi: 10.1176/appi.ps.53.8.958.
The authors evaluated the second of the two core questions around which the ACCESS (Access to Community Care and Effective Services and Supports) evaluation was designed: Does better integration of service systems improve the treatment outcomes of homeless persons with severe mental illness?
The ACCESS program provided technical support and about $250,000 a year for four years to nine sites to implement strategies to promote systems integration. These sites, along with nine comparison sites, also received funds to support outreach and assertive community treatment programs to assist 100 clients a year at each site. Outcome data were obtained at baseline and three and 12 months later from 7,055 clients across four annual cohorts at all sites.
Clients at all sites demonstrated improvement in outcome measures. However, the clients at the experimental sites showed no greater improvement on measures of mental health or housing outcomes across the four cohorts than those at the comparison sites. More extensive implementation of systems integration strategies was unrelated to these outcomes. However, clients of sites that became more integrated, regardless of the degree of implementation or whether the sites were experimental sites or comparison sites, had progressively better housing outcomes.
Interventions designed to increase the level of systems integration in the ACCESS demonstration did not result in better client outcomes.
作者评估了ACCESS(获得社区护理及有效服务与支持)评估所围绕的两个核心问题中的第二个:服务系统的更好整合是否能改善患有严重精神疾病的无家可归者的治疗结果?
ACCESS项目在四年时间里每年为九个地点提供技术支持及约25万美元,以实施促进系统整合的策略。这些地点以及九个对照地点还获得资金,以支持外展服务和积极社区治疗项目,每个地点每年协助100名客户。在基线以及之后三个月和十二个月时,从所有地点四个年度队列的7055名客户那里获取了结果数据。
所有地点的客户在结果指标方面都有改善。然而,在四个队列中,实验地点的客户在心理健康或住房结果指标上的改善并不比对照地点的客户更大。系统整合策略的更广泛实施与这些结果无关。然而,无论实施程度如何,也无论这些地点是实验地点还是对照地点,变得更加整合的地点的客户住房结果逐渐更好。
旨在提高ACCESS示范项目中系统整合水平的干预措施并未带来更好的客户结果。