Badrick Tony C, Preston Arthur P
International Graduate School of Management, University of South Australia, Adelaide, South Australia.
Clin Leadersh Manag Rev. 2002 Sep-Oct;16(5):281-6.
The reliance of organizations on consultants generally is increasing. Although the efficacy of the use of consultants in implementing change programs has been questioned, there have been limited attempts to systematically analyze the contribution of consultants. This article reports observations on the use of consultants in health-care organizations implementing total quality management (TQM). The relationship between the use of external management consultants and successful TQM implementation is not simple. There appears to be a difference in the way consultants are used by the public and private sectors, with the private organizations forming long-term relationships with their consultants. The perceived value of consultants to the private organizations was higher. Consultants are not a substitute for leadership, and the success of outside consultants probably depends on the commitment of senior management. External management consultants appeared to be linked to the successful implementation of TQM. Further, despite the conventional wisdom to the contrary, some prepackaged programs may be beneficial for the introduction of TQM into an organization.
组织对顾问的依赖总体上在增加。尽管在实施变革计划时使用顾问的效果受到了质疑,但系统分析顾问贡献的尝试却很有限。本文报告了在实施全面质量管理(TQM)的医疗保健组织中使用顾问的观察结果。外部管理顾问的使用与成功实施TQM之间的关系并不简单。公共部门和私营部门使用顾问的方式似乎存在差异,私营组织与他们的顾问建立了长期关系。私营组织对顾问的感知价值更高。顾问不能替代领导力,外部顾问的成功可能取决于高级管理层的承诺。外部管理顾问似乎与TQM的成功实施有关。此外,尽管传统观念相反,但一些预包装计划可能有利于将TQM引入组织。