Slavin Shimon, Aker Mehmet, Shapira Michael Y, Panigrahi Soumya, Gabriel Cividalli, Or Reuven
Department of Bone Marrow Transplantation & Cancer Immunotherapy, Hadassah University Hospital, Jerusalem, Israel.
Transfus Apher Sci. 2002 Oct;27(2):159-66. doi: 10.1016/s1473-0502(02)00038-1.
Allogeneic bone marrow or blood stem cell transplantation (BMT) represents an important therapeutic tool for treatment of otherwise incurable malignant and non-malignant diseases. Until recently, autologous and allogeneic bone marrow or mobilized blood stem cells transplantation were used primarily to replace malignant, genetically abnormal or deficient immunohematopoietic compartment and therefore, highly toxic myeloablative regimen were considered mandatory for more effective eradication of all undesirable host-derived hematopoietic elements. Our preclinical and ongoing clinical studies indicated that much more effective eradication of host immunohematopoietic system cells could be achieved by adoptive allogeneic cell therapy with donor lymphocyte infusion following BMT. Thus, eradication of blood cancer cells, especially in patients with CML and less frequently in patients with other hematologic malignancies, could be frequently accomplished despite complete resistance of such tumor cells to maximally tolerated doses of chemoradiotherapy. Our cumulative experience suggested that graft versus leukemia (GVL) effects might be a useful tool for eradication of otherwise resistant tumor cells of host origin. Based on the cumulative clinical experience and experimental data in animal models of human diseases it appears that induction of host versus graft tolerance as step one, may allow durable engraftment of donor immunocompetent lymphocytes, which may be used for induction of effective biologic warfare against host-type immunohematopoietic cells that need to be replaced, malignant, genetically abnormal or self-reactive alike. Based on the aforementioned rationale, we speculated that the therapeutic benefit of BMT may be improved by using a safer conditioning as part of the transplant procedure, with the goal in mind to induce host versus graft tolerance to enable subsequent induction of GVL, possibly graft versus tumor or even graft versus autoimmunity effects, rather than attempt to eliminate host cells with hazardous myeloablative chemoradiotherapy. The latter hypothesis suggested that effective BMT procedure may be accomplished without lethal conditioning of the host, using new well tolerated non-myeloablative regimen, thus possibly minimizing immediate and late side effects related to myeloablative procedures considered until recently mandatory for conditioning of BMT recipients. Recent clinical data that will be presented suggests that effective BMT procedures may be accomplished with well-tolerated non-myeloablative stem cell transplantation (NST) regimen, with no major toxicity. Thus, new NST approaches may offer the feasibility of safer BMT procedure for a large spectrum of clinical indications in children and elderly individuals without lower or upper age limit, while minimizing procedure-related toxicity and mortality. Taken together, our cumulative data suggest that high dose chemotherapy and radiation therapy may be successively replaced by a more effective biologic tool, alloreactive donor lymphocytes, thus setting the stage for innovative therapeutic procedures for safer and more effective treatment of patients in need of BMT.
异基因骨髓或血液干细胞移植(BMT)是治疗其他方法无法治愈的恶性和非恶性疾病的重要治疗手段。直到最近,自体和异基因骨髓或动员的血液干细胞移植主要用于替代恶性、基因异常或有缺陷的免疫造血系统,因此,人们认为高毒性的清髓方案对于更有效地根除所有不需要的宿主来源的造血成分是必不可少的。我们的临床前和正在进行的临床研究表明,在BMT后通过供体淋巴细胞输注进行过继性异基因细胞治疗,可以更有效地根除宿主免疫造血系统细胞。因此,尽管血液癌细胞对最大耐受剂量的放化疗完全耐药,但仍能经常实现对其的根除,尤其是在慢性粒细胞白血病患者中,在其他血液系统恶性肿瘤患者中则较少见。我们的累积经验表明,移植物抗白血病(GVL)效应可能是根除宿主来源的耐药肿瘤细胞的有用工具。基于人类疾病动物模型的累积临床经验和实验数据,似乎作为第一步诱导宿主对移植物的耐受性,可能会使供体免疫活性淋巴细胞持久植入,可以用于对需要替代的宿主型免疫造血细胞发动有效的生物战,这些细胞无论是恶性、基因异常还是自身反应性的。基于上述原理,我们推测,通过使用更安全的预处理作为移植程序的一部分,可以提高BMT的治疗效果,目的是诱导宿主对移植物的耐受性,以便随后诱导GVL,可能是移植物抗肿瘤甚至移植物抗自身免疫效应,而不是试图用危险的清髓性放化疗消除宿主细胞。后一种假设表明,有效的BMT程序可以在不对宿主进行致死性预处理的情况下完成,使用新的耐受性良好的非清髓方案,从而可能将与清髓程序相关的近期和远期副作用降至最低,直到最近,人们还认为清髓程序是BMT受者预处理所必需的。即将展示的最新临床数据表明,有效的BMT程序可以通过耐受性良好的非清髓性干细胞移植(NST)方案完成,且无重大毒性。因此,新的NST方法可能为儿童和老年人的广泛临床适应证提供更安全的BMT程序的可行性,不受年龄上限或下限限制,同时将与手术相关的毒性和死亡率降至最低。综上所述,我们的累积数据表明,高剂量化疗和放疗可能会相继被一种更有效的生物工具——同种异体反应性供体淋巴细胞所取代,从而为需要BMT的患者制定更安全、更有效的创新治疗程序奠定基础。