Ohmori Masako, Wada Masako, Nishii Kenji, Nakazono Tomoaki, Masuyama Hidenori, Yoshiyama Takashi, Inaba Keiko, Itoh Kunihiko, Uchimura Kazuhiro, Saegusa Mihoko, Mitarai Satoshi, Kimura Moriyo, Shimouchi Akira
Research Institute of Tuberculosis, Okayama Institute of Health and Prevention, Japan.
Kekkaku. 2002 Oct;77(10):647-58.
The notification rate of tuberculosis in Japan was 31.0 per 100,000 in 2000. The rate was especially high among the elderly population, reaching 85.5 per 100,000 among those over 65 years of age. We conducted a study of preventive therapy in middle-aged and elderly persons selected from the population-based screening by the mass miniature radiography. The eligible criteria were 50-79 years of age, fibrous lesion which were compatible with healed tuberculosis and showed no change for at least one year, no previous treatment for tuberculosis, normal liver function tests, and no serious disease at the time of study. The eligible criteria for liver function tests in this study was less than 50 IU/L of AST and ALT value, and less than 1.5 mg/dl of T-bil level. A total of 13,219 people underwent TB screening in 4 cities in 1997 and 2 cities in 1998. Among them, 440 persons fulfilled the above criteria based on the screening records and chest X-ray films. The municipal offices sent letters to 418 people, except 22 whose addresses were unknown, to obtain permission to use their addresses and results of screening in our study. Permission was obtained from 137 persons and we sent them invitation letters for cost-free physical checkup service. Ninety-five persons visited us, and we offered them physical checkup and explained about our study. After obtaining the informed consent, we performed chest X-ray and sputum examination for 3 consecutive days. Finally 29 people were enrolled in the study. They were divided into 4 groups by sex and age, and were randomly assigned to one of two treatment groups. One group took 300 mg of INH per day for 6 months and the other group was only followed up by chest X-ray. Fourteen out of 29 persons began to take INH and received monthly liver function test. All the subjects were scheduled to follow by medical checkup every 6 months for 5 years. The proportion of taking INH tablets was estimated to range from 94% to 100%, based on the calendar for record of taking medication and the number of remaining tablets each month. Six (42.9%) of 14 persons reported adverse reactions. Two of 6 persons complained some of diarrhea, vomiting and gastrointestinal disturbance within 2 weeks, and discontinued taking INH, although none of them showed abnormal liver function tests. Two of 6 persons who reported some kinds of symptoms and 2 of 8 persons who did not complain of any symptoms showed abnormal liver function tests. The abnormal liver function tests had developed from 2 months after the beginning of INH taking in most of the persons and the abnormality improved after the completion of 6-month treatment. We have followed them for a maximum duration of 2.5 years, and 3 cases dropped out from the study. These defaulted cases had completed 6 months of INH. One person (69 y.o. male) was diagnosed as active TB by his chest X-ray film at the 6th month medical checkup, although it was not confirmed bacteriologically. One person (62 y.o. female) had the mastectomy for breast cancer 7 months before the entry to this study and relapsed at the 8th month after the entry. One person (73 y.o. female) was diagnosed as lung cancer at the medical checkup on 2.5 years. Besides them, 4 persons were suspected of worsening the abnormal shadows on chest X-ray films; one was from the INH group and three were from the follow-up group. However none of them was diagnosed clinically and bacteriologically as active tuberculosis.
2000年日本结核病的报告发病率为每10万人31.0例。该发病率在老年人群中尤其高,65岁以上人群达到每10万人85.5例。我们对通过大规模微型放射摄影从人群筛查中选取的中老年人进行了预防性治疗研究。入选标准为年龄50 - 79岁,有与愈合性结核病相符且至少一年无变化的纤维病灶,既往未接受过结核病治疗,肝功能检查正常,且研究时无严重疾病。本研究中肝功能检查的入选标准为谷草转氨酶(AST)和谷丙转氨酶(ALT)值低于50 IU/L,总胆红素(T - bil)水平低于1.5 mg/dl。1997年在4个城市以及1998年在2个城市共有13219人接受了结核病筛查。其中,根据筛查记录和胸部X线片,有440人符合上述标准。市政办公室给418人(除22人地址不明外)写信,以获取在我们研究中使用其地址和筛查结果的许可。获得了137人的许可,我们给他们发送了免费体检服务的邀请信。95人前来就诊,我们为他们进行了体检并解释了我们的研究。在获得知情同意后,我们连续3天为他们进行了胸部X线和痰液检查。最终29人被纳入研究。他们按性别和年龄分为4组,并随机分配到两个治疗组之一。一组每天服用300 mg异烟肼,持续6个月,另一组仅通过胸部X线进行随访。29人中14人开始服用异烟肼并每月进行肝功能检查。根据服药记录日历和每月剩余药片数量估计,服用异烟肼片的比例在94%至100%之间。14人中有6人(42.9%)报告了不良反应。6人中2人在2周内出现了一些腹泻、呕吐和胃肠道不适,并停止服用异烟肼,尽管他们的肝功能检查均未显示异常。报告有某种症状的6人中2人以及未抱怨任何症状的8人中2人肝功能检查显示异常。大多数人肝功能检查异常在开始服用异烟肼2个月后出现,6个月治疗结束后异常情况有所改善。我们对他们进行了最长2.5年的随访,有3例退出研究。这些违约病例已完成6个月的异烟肼治疗。一名69岁男性在第6个月体检时胸部X线片诊断为活动性结核病,尽管细菌学未确诊。一名62岁女性在进入本研究前7个月因乳腺癌接受了乳房切除术,进入研究后第8个月复发。一名73岁女性在2.5年体检时被诊断为肺癌。除此之外,4人胸部X线片上疑似异常阴影加重;1人来自异烟肼组,3人来自随访组。然而他们中没有一人在临床和细菌学上被诊断为活动性结核病。