Teng Josephine, Mayo Nancy E, Latimer Eric, Hanley Jim, Wood-Dauphinee Sharon, Côté Robert, Scott Susan
Joint Department of Biostatistics and Epidemiology and Occupational Health, Faculty of Medicine, McGill University, Montreal, Quebec, Canada.
Stroke. 2003 Feb;34(2):528-36. doi: 10.1161/01.str.0000049767.14156.2c.
Early supported discharge (ESD) for stroke has been shown to yield outcomes similar to or better than those of conventional care, but there is less information on the impact on costs and on the caregiver. The purpose of this study is to estimate the costs associated with an ESD program compared with those of usual care.
We conducted a randomized controlled trial of stroke patients who required rehabilitation services and who had a caregiver at home.
Acute-care costs incurred before randomization when patients were medically ready for discharge averaged $3251 per person. The costs for the balance of the acute-care stay, from randomization to discharge, were $1383 for the home group and $2220 for the usual care group. The average cost of providing the 4-week home intervention service was $943 per person. The total cost generated by persons assigned to the home group averaged $7784 per person, significantly lower than the $11 065 per person for those assigned to usual care. A large proportion of the cost differential between the 2 groups arose from readmissions, for which the usual care group generated costs more than quadruple those of the home intervention group.
Providing care at home was no more (or less) expensive for those with greater functional limitation than for those with less. Caregivers in the ESD group scored consistently lower on the Burden Index than caregivers with usual care, even caregivers of persons with major functional limitations. For persons recovering from stroke and their families, ESD provides a cost-effective alternative to usual care.
卒中早期支持性出院(ESD)已被证明能产生与传统护理相似或更好的结果,但关于其对成本和照料者的影响的信息较少。本研究的目的是估计与ESD项目相关的成本,并与常规护理的成本进行比较。
我们对需要康复服务且家中有照料者的卒中患者进行了一项随机对照试验。
在患者符合医学出院标准时,随机分组前的急性护理费用平均每人3251美元。从随机分组到出院期间,家庭组急性护理剩余时间的费用为1383美元,常规护理组为2220美元。提供为期4周的家庭干预服务的平均成本为每人943美元。家庭组患者产生的总成本平均每人7784美元,显著低于常规护理组的每人11065美元。两组之间很大一部分成本差异源于再入院,常规护理组产生的再入院成本是家庭干预组的四倍多。
对于功能受限程度较高的患者,在家中提供护理的成本并不高于(或低于)功能受限程度较低的患者。ESD组的照料者在负担指数上的得分始终低于接受常规护理的照料者,即使是照料功能严重受限患者的照料者。对于从中风恢复的患者及其家人来说,ESD是一种比常规护理更具成本效益的选择。