Matsuura Maiko, Lounici Smain, Inoue Nozomu, Walulik Stephen, Chao Edmund Y S
Orthopaedic Biomechanics Laboratory, School of Medicine, Johns Hopkins University, 720 Rutland Avenue, Baltimore, MD 21205-2196, USA.
Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2003 Jan(406):275-81. doi: 10.1097/01.blo.0000037443.23683.7c.
No standard method has been established for investigating repeated use of an external fixator. The purpose of the current study was to establish a fatigue testing method for assessing fixator frame reuse. A unilateral DynaFix trade mark external fixator system was tested using high-load and low-cycle (900-150 N at 5 Hz) and low-load and high-cycle (450-100 N at 10 Hz) tests (assumed one use of 500,000 and 1 million cycles, respectively). These loading conditions were selected to simulate single clinical use and to satisfy Food and Drug Administration requirements. In the high-load low-cycle test, substantial failure of the serrated joint occurred before completion of the first simulated use. In the low-load high-cycle test, all fixators completed three simulated clinical uses without failure, although (1/4) of the serrated joint components had hairline cracks. The high-load low-cycle test identified the fixator components which should be examined and replaced if reuse of the fixator is to be considered. Wear and deformation of the set screw on the rotary joint and telescoping mechanisms were observed in the low-load high-cycle test but not in the high-load low-cycle test. Therefore, if the unilateral DynaFix trade mark fixators are being considered for reusability, the number of reuses should be limited as the whole structure of the device will experience fatigue damage as the loading cycle increases.
目前尚未建立用于研究外固定器重复使用的标准方法。本研究的目的是建立一种疲劳测试方法,以评估固定器框架的再利用情况。使用单侧DynaFix商标外固定器系统进行了高负荷低循环(5Hz下900 - 150N)和低负荷高循环(10Hz下450 - 100N)测试(分别假设一次使用500,000次和1,000,000次循环)。选择这些加载条件是为了模拟单次临床使用并满足美国食品药品监督管理局的要求。在高负荷低循环测试中,锯齿状关节在首次模拟使用完成前就发生了严重故障。在低负荷高循环测试中,所有固定器都完成了三次模拟临床使用且未出现故障,尽管(1/4)的锯齿状关节部件出现了细微裂纹。高负荷低循环测试确定了如果要考虑固定器重利用就应检查和更换的固定器部件。在低负荷高循环测试中观察到了旋转接头和伸缩机构上紧定螺钉的磨损和变形,但在高负荷低循环测试中未观察到。因此,如果考虑单侧DynaFix商标固定器的可重复使用性,随着加载循环次数的增加,由于装置的整体结构会受到疲劳损伤,重复使用的次数应受到限制。