Rikard-Bell G, Donnelly N, Ward J
South West Sydney Area Health Service, Liverpool, Australia.
Br Dent J. 2003 Feb 8;194(3):159-64; discussion 150. doi: 10.1038/sj.bdj.4809899.
To investigate patients' views regarding dentists' smoking cessation advice.
Survey questionnaire.
One hundred and thirty five dental practices in Sydney Australia. Subjects Two thousand, four hundred and fifty one dental patients.
One thousand, one hundred and sixty pre-consultation questionnaires were obtained (RR=80%), 302 (26%) were self-reported smokers. From these, 623 post-consultation questionnaires were returned (RR = 54%). Most patients expected dentists to be interested in their smoking status (n = 847/1160, 73%, 95% CI: 70% to 76%) and to discuss smoking with them (n = 713/1160, 61%, 95% CI: 59% to 64%), however, smokers were significantly less likely to respond as such compared with non-smokers (P < 0.001). Smokers and non-smokers equally would not change dentist even if asked about their smoking status opportunistically (59% versus 62%) (OR = 0.91, 95% CI: 0.67 to 1.22). Less than one third of all smokers would try to quit if their dentist suggested they do so (n = 90/302, 30%, 95% CI: 25% to 35%). Smokers' recall of quit advice from their recent consultation was low (n = 22/124, 18%).
Smoking cessation advice by dentists is not self-evidently effective. These findings behove interventional research to ascertain efficacy of smoking cessation advice delivered by dentists before admonishing changes in routine clinical practice.
调查患者对牙医戒烟建议的看法。
调查问卷。
澳大利亚悉尼的135家牙科诊所。对象:2451名牙科患者。
获得了1160份咨询前问卷(回复率=80%),其中302人(26%)自述为吸烟者。在这些吸烟者中,623份咨询后问卷被收回(回复率=54%)。大多数患者期望牙医关注他们的吸烟状况(n = 847/1160,73%,95%置信区间:70%至76%)并与他们讨论吸烟问题(n = 713/1160,61%,95%置信区间:59%至64%),然而,与非吸烟者相比,吸烟者做出这种回应的可能性显著更低(P < 0.001)。吸烟者和非吸烟者即使被机会性地问及吸烟状况,同样不太可能更换牙医(分别为59%和62%)(比值比=0.91,95%置信区间:0.67至1.22)。如果牙医建议戒烟,所有吸烟者中不到三分之一会尝试戒烟(n = 90/302,30%,95%置信区间:25%至35%)。吸烟者对近期咨询中戒烟建议的回忆率较低(n = 22/124,18%)。
牙医的戒烟建议并非显然有效。这些发现促使进行干预性研究,以在常规临床实践发生改变之前确定牙医提供的戒烟建议的效果。