Henry Chantal, Demotes-Mainard Jacques
Service Universitaire de Psychiatrie, CH Charles Perrens, Bordeaux, France.
Drug Saf. 2003;26(5):337-51. doi: 10.2165/00002018-200326050-00003.
Antidepressant-induced switching is a major risk during the treatment of bipolar depression. Despite several clinical studies, questions remain regarding both the definition of these mood switches and the most appropriate therapeutic strategy to avoid this adverse effect. This review will first briefly consider the current guidelines for the acute treatment of bipolar depression. We will then review the mechanisms of action of antidepressant and mood stabilisers, and the switches induced by various types of antidepressant treatments, or triggered by antidepressant withdrawal, as well as by atypical antipsychotics. We then will address the risk of mood switch according to the type of mood stabiliser used. The propensity to mood switches in bipolar patients is subject to individual differences. Therefore we will describe both the clinical and biological characteristics of patients prone to mood switches under antidepressant treatment. However, the clinical characteristics of the depressive syndrome may also be a key determinant for mood switches. Various data help identify the most appropriate drug management strategies for avoiding mood switches during the treatment of bipolar depression. Selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors appear to be the drugs of first-choice because of the low associated risk of mood switching. Antidepressants must be associated with a mood stabiliser and the most effective in the prevention of switches seems to be lithium. Whatever the mood stabiliser used, effective plasma levels must be ensured. The optimal duration of antidepressant treatment for bipolar depression is still an open issue - prolonged treatments after recovery may be unnecessary and may facilitate mood elation. Moreover, some mood episodes with mixed symptoms can be worsened by antidepressants pointing to the need for a better delineation of the categories of symptoms requiring antidepressant treatment. Finally, as a result of this review, we suggest some propositions to define drug-induced switches in bipolar patients, and to try to delineate which strategies should be recommended in clinical practice to reduce as far as possible the risk of mood switch during the treatment of bipolar depression.
抗抑郁药诱发的转相是双相抑郁治疗期间的主要风险。尽管有多项临床研究,但关于这些情绪转相的定义以及避免这种不良反应的最恰当治疗策略仍存在疑问。本综述将首先简要探讨双相抑郁急性治疗的现行指南。然后,我们将回顾抗抑郁药和心境稳定剂的作用机制,以及各类抗抑郁治疗诱发的转相,或由抗抑郁药撤药引发的转相,还有非典型抗精神病药物引发的转相。接着,我们将根据所用心境稳定剂的类型探讨情绪转相的风险。双相患者发生情绪转相的倾向存在个体差异。因此,我们将描述在抗抑郁治疗下易于发生情绪转相的患者的临床和生物学特征。然而,抑郁综合征的临床特征也可能是情绪转相的关键决定因素。各种数据有助于确定在双相抑郁治疗期间避免情绪转相的最恰当药物管理策略。选择性5-羟色胺再摄取抑制剂似乎是首选药物,因为其引发情绪转相的相关风险较低。抗抑郁药必须与心境稳定剂联用,预防转相最有效的似乎是锂盐。无论使用何种心境稳定剂,都必须确保达到有效的血药浓度。双相抑郁抗抑郁治疗的最佳疗程仍是一个悬而未决的问题——康复后延长治疗可能并无必要,且可能会促使情绪高涨。此外,一些伴有混合症状的情绪发作可能会因抗抑郁药而恶化,这表明需要更好地界定需要抗抑郁治疗的症状类别。最后,基于本综述的结果,我们提出一些建议,以界定双相患者中药物诱发的转相,并试图勾勒出在临床实践中应推荐哪些策略,以尽可能降低双相抑郁治疗期间情绪转相的风险。