Beck Susan J, Doig Kathy
Division of Clinical Laboratory Science, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, NC 27599-7145, USA.
Clin Lab Sci. 2002 Fall;15(4):220-8.
The study was undertaken to assess educators', practitioners', and managers' perceptions of the future job expectations of clinical laboratory scientists (CLSs) and their opinions on the skills that are expected of CLSs at entry-level and with experience.
Survey participants were given a list of 44 competencies related to clinical laboratory science (CLS) practice and were asked whether they would expect a graduate of a respected CLS program to perform each competency in one of three educational categories: the first year of practice, with three to five years of experience but no additional education, or with three to five years of experience plus additional education. The competencies were subclassified into one of four major management functions: laboratory operations, human resource management, financial operations, or communications/consultation. Surveys also included eight Lickert-type questions designed to assess the respondents' opinions on the future job expectations of CLS practitioners.
The sample for the survey included 280 directors of CLS educational programs, 600 managers randomly selected from the Clinical Laboratory Management Association (CLMA) membership, and 600 practitioners randomly selected from the American Society for Clinical Laboratory Science (ASCLS) membership.
The percent of respondents selecting each educational category was tabulated and each competency was assigned to one educational category based onthe highest percent of respondents selecting that category. The means of the responses to the Lickert-type questions were calculated for all respondents and for each group of respondents (educators, managers, and practitioners).
Response rates of 58% (educators), 28% (practitioners), and 39% (managers) were obtained. Of the 44 competencies in the survey, four were expected at career-entry, 17 were expected of CLS graduates with work experience but no additional education, and 23 were expected of CLS graduates with experience plus additional education. Competencies expected in the first year of practice were primarily scientific and technical. With three to five years of practice and no additional education, the expectations for practitioners were primarily in laboratory operations and communications/consultation areas. The majority of the human resource management and financial operations competencies were expected with three to five years of practice and additional education. All participants agreed that CLS staff-level practitioners need more management and administrative skills and that, in the future, CLS practitioners will spend less time performing laboratory tests and more time solving problems. CLS managers were more positive than CLS educators in response to statements asserting that CLT practitioners and non-certified personnel will have an increased role in the laboratory in the future.
This study suggests that extensive laboratory operations and communication skills are expected of CLS graduates without any additional education beyond their CLS programs. CLS educators should adequately address those areas in the curriculum. Competence in other non-technical skills may not be expected without the benefit of post-baccalaureate education and in these areas, CLS programs can provide a foundation for future learning.
本研究旨在评估教育工作者、从业者和管理人员对临床检验科学家(CLS)未来工作期望的看法,以及他们对CLS入门级和有工作经验者所需技能的意见。
调查参与者收到一份与临床检验科学(CLS)实践相关的44项能力清单,并被问及他们是否期望一个受认可的CLS项目的毕业生在以下三个教育类别中的某一个中具备每项能力:执业第一年、有三至五年工作经验但无额外教育、有三至五年工作经验且有额外教育。这些能力被细分为四个主要管理职能之一:实验室运营、人力资源管理、财务运营或沟通/咨询。调查还包括八个利克特类型的问题,旨在评估受访者对CLS从业者未来工作期望的意见。
调查样本包括280名CLS教育项目主任、从临床实验室管理协会(CLMA)会员中随机挑选的600名管理人员,以及从美国临床检验科学学会(ASCLS)会员中随机挑选的600名从业者。
将选择每个教育类别的受访者百分比制成表格,并根据选择该类别的受访者的最高百分比将每项能力归入一个教育类别。计算所有受访者以及每组受访者(教育工作者、管理人员和从业者)对利克特类型问题的回答的平均值。
获得了58%(教育工作者)、28%(从业者)和39%(管理人员)的回复率。在调查的44项能力中,4项能力是职业生涯入门时所期望的,17项能力是对有工作经验但无额外教育的CLS毕业生的期望,23项能力是对有经验且有额外教育的CLS毕业生的期望。执业第一年所期望的能力主要是科学和技术方面的。有三至五年工作经验且无额外教育时,对从业者的期望主要在实验室运营和沟通/咨询领域。大多数人力资源管理和财务运营能力是在有三至五年工作经验且有额外教育时所期望的。所有参与者都认为CLS基层从业者需要更多的管理和行政技能,并且未来CLS从业者将花更少的时间进行实验室检测,而花更多时间解决问题。在回应关于CLT从业者和非认证人员未来在实验室中将发挥更大作用的陈述时,CLS管理人员比CLS教育工作者更积极。
本研究表明,对于CLS毕业生,在其CLS项目之外没有任何额外教育的情况下,期望他们具备广泛的实验室运营和沟通技能。CLS教育工作者应在课程中充分涵盖这些领域。没有本科后教育的情况下,可能无法期望在其他非技术技能方面具备能力,在这些领域,CLS项目可以为未来的学习奠定基础。