Picard D, Carvalho P, Bonnavia C, Louin L, Josset V, Lauret Ph, Joly P
Clinique Dermatologique, CHU de Rouen.
Ann Dermatol Venereol. 2003 May;130(5):507-10.
The official policy of the French National Health Insurance system is to deny reimbursement for drugs prescribed for off-label indications. The objectives of this study were 1) to quantify the use of off-label prescriptions by physicians from a hospital department of dermatology in France; 2) to characterize these off-label prescriptions; 3) to assess data from the literature on the appropriateness of these off-label prescriptions.
For each patient consulting between February 1 and April 1, 2001, the symptom or the disease that was treated and the type of prescription were recorded on standard forms.
Eighty six percent of prescriptions were labelled, 14 p. 100 were off-labelled. Inflammatory and hypersensitivity dermatoses were the most frequent indications of off-label prescriptions (26 p. 100). Treatments which most frequently corresponded to off-label prescriptions were topical corticosteroids and methotrexate. Examination of the literature showed that 70 p. 100 of the off-label prescriptions were not based on strong data from evidence-based-medicine. Many off-label prescriptions were made by the most graduate physicians.
This study showed a great number of off-label prescriptions in dermatology. These prescriptions were often related to rare diseases that were managed by senior dermatologists. These off-label prescriptions were rarely in accordance with data from evidence-based-medicine.
法国国家医疗保险系统的官方政策是拒绝报销用于非适应症的药物处方费用。本研究的目的是:1)量化法国一家医院皮肤科医生开具的非适应症处方的使用情况;2)描述这些非适应症处方的特征;3)评估文献中有关这些非适应症处方合理性的数据。
对于2001年2月1日至4月1日期间就诊的每位患者,在标准表格上记录所治疗的症状或疾病以及处方类型。
86%的处方为适应症内用药,14%为非适应症用药。炎症性和过敏性皮肤病是最常见的非适应症用药指征(占26%)。最常与非适应症处方相对应的治疗药物是外用皮质类固醇和甲氨蝶呤。文献研究表明,70%的非适应症处方并非基于循证医学的有力数据。许多非适应症处方是由资历最深的医生开具的。
本研究表明皮肤科存在大量非适应症处方。这些处方往往与由资深皮肤科医生诊治的罕见疾病有关。这些非适应症处方很少符合循证医学的数据。