Jones Sonya J, Jahns Lisa, Laraia Barbara A, Haughton Betsy
Department of Nutrition, University of Tennessee, Knoxville 37996, USA.
Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 2003 Aug;157(8):780-4. doi: 10.1001/archpedi.157.8.780.
A quarter of US children are at increased risk of obesity-related health problems because of excess weight. The few national studies of child overweight and inadequate household resources available to purchase healthy foods, or food insecurity, have shown inconsistent results. We hypothesized that the inconsistency in these results may be attributed to a differential effect of participation in food assistance programs in food secure and food insecure households.
Using the 1997 Panel Study of Income Dynamics Child Development Supplement, we compared the risk of a child aged 5 to 12 years being at or above the 85th percentile of body mass index for age in food insecure and food secure, low-income households when controlling for participation in the Food Stamp Program and the national school lunch and breakfast programs as well as other covariates.
We found that food insecure girls who participated in all 3 programs had a 68% reduced odds (odds ratio, 0.32; 95% confidence interval, 0.12-0.77) of being at risk of overweight when compared with food insecure girls in nonparticipating households and controlling for other factors. Girls in food secure households generally had no greater or less risk of overweight if they participated in any or all programs. Boys in both food insecure and food secure households had no greater or less risk of overweight by if they participated in any or all of the programs.
These results support our hypothesis that food assistance programs play a protective role for low-income children's health, particularly in girls in food insecure households.
由于体重超标,美国四分之一的儿童面临与肥胖相关的健康问题风险增加。关于儿童超重以及家庭缺乏购买健康食品的资源(即粮食不安全)的少数全国性研究结果并不一致。我们推测,这些结果的不一致可能归因于粮食安全和粮食不安全家庭参与粮食援助计划的不同影响。
利用1997年收入动态研究儿童发展补充调查,我们比较了5至12岁儿童在粮食不安全和粮食安全的低收入家庭中,在控制食品券计划、国家学校午餐和早餐计划以及其他协变量的情况下,体重指数处于或高于年龄别第85百分位数的风险。
我们发现,与未参与计划的粮食不安全家庭中的女孩相比,参与所有这三项计划的粮食不安全女孩超重风险降低了68%(优势比,0.32;95%置信区间,0.12 - 0.77),且控制了其他因素。粮食安全家庭中的女孩,如果参与任何一项或所有计划,超重风险通常没有更大或更小。粮食不安全和粮食安全家庭中的男孩,无论参与任何一项或所有计划,超重风险都没有更大或更小。
这些结果支持了我们的假设,即粮食援助计划对低收入儿童的健康起到保护作用,尤其是对粮食不安全家庭中的女孩。