Kanazawa Hidemi, Tanaka Hiroyuki, Inoue Masaru, Yamanaka Yoshitaka, Namba Noriyuki, Seino Yoshiki
Department of Pediatrics, Okayama University Graduate School of Medicine and Dentistry, 2-5-1 Shikata-cho, 700-8558 Okayama, Japan.
J Bone Miner Metab. 2003;21(5):307-10. doi: 10.1007/s00774-003-0425-7.
Most patients with skeletal dysplasia show severe short stature. Surgical therapy has been attempted to correct bone deformities, but therapy for improving their severe short stature has been rarely attempted. We undertook a clinical trial of growth hormone (GH) therapy for patients with skeletal dysplasia accompanying severe short stature caused by achondroplasia (ACH), hypochondroplasia (HCH), pseudoachondroplasia (PSACH), spondyloepiphyseal dysplasia congenita (SED), or Schmid type metaphyseal dysplasia (MD). This study examined the efficacy of GH therapy on height increase and change of height SD score over a 1-year period in patients with skeletal dysplasia and showed a short-term efficacy for skeletal dysplasia. In ACH, HCH, and MD, GH had a significant effect on height gain. However, PSACH and SED showed no height gain efficacy; in cases of PSACH, height SD score was worse after therapy. Severe adverse events were not observed except in one SED case, in which scoliosis worsened and height did not increase. For patients with skeletal dysplasia, GH therapy is moderately effective for height gain. It is ineffective in cases with severe spinal deformities, however; although bone growth was promoted, the ligaments and matrix were too weak to support muscle tonus and the effects of gravity, resulting in worsened kyphosis and lordosis. These results clarify why GH therapy is ineffective for height gain. The pathogenic genes of skeletal dysplasia have recently been detected and consequently changes in bone formation have been investigated in detail. Careful consideration of indications for therapy and cautious observation during therapy are crucial when attempting to treat advanced bone deformities.
大多数骨骼发育不良患者表现出严重身材矮小。人们曾尝试通过手术治疗来矫正骨骼畸形,但很少有人尝试改善他们严重身材矮小的治疗方法。我们对因软骨发育不全(ACH)、低软骨发育不全(HCH)、假性软骨发育不全(PSACH)、先天性脊柱骨骺发育不良(SED)或施密德型干骺端发育不良(MD)导致严重身材矮小的骨骼发育不良患者进行了生长激素(GH)治疗的临床试验。本研究考察了GH治疗对骨骼发育不良患者1年内身高增长及身高标准差评分变化的疗效,并显示了对骨骼发育不良的短期疗效。在ACH、HCH和MD中,GH对身高增长有显著影响。然而PSACH和SED未显示出身高增长疗效;在PSACH病例中,治疗后身高标准差评分更差。除1例SED病例外,未观察到严重不良事件,该例患者脊柱侧弯加重且身高未增加。对于骨骼发育不良患者,GH治疗对身高增长有一定疗效。然而,在严重脊柱畸形的病例中无效;尽管促进了骨骼生长,但韧带和基质过于薄弱,无法支撑肌肉张力和重力作用,导致后凸和前凸加重。这些结果阐明了为什么GH治疗对身高增长无效。最近已检测到骨骼发育不良的致病基因,因此对骨形成的变化进行了详细研究。在尝试治疗晚期骨骼畸形时,仔细考虑治疗指征并在治疗期间谨慎观察至关重要。